This post reflects on fieldwork encounters in Samsun’s medical device industry, where questions of recognition, circulation, and survival are deeply entangled. From steel traveling in absurd loops across continents to “paper walls” of regulation that preserve European dominance, the narratives reveal how innovation in the Global Majority is often rendered invisible. What emerges is a story of epistemic asymmetry: whose labor counts, whose knowledge is recognized, and how survival strategies reshape entire industries.
A Quote That Stays with Me
“When the same instrument carries a German stamp, it is praised. When it comes from us, customers turn up their noses.”
This sentence, spoken during the MediCluster project fieldwork in Samsun (Türkiye), captures the heart of what Science and Technology Studies (STS) calls epistemic asymmetry. It is not only about where knowledge is produced, but about whose knowledge counts, whose products are recognized, and whose labor remains invisible.
Circulation without Recognition
One of the most striking observations from my observation is the way material itself circulates across borders. A producer described an almost absurd supply chain:
Steel is sent from Tuttlingen (Germany) to Sialkot (Pakistan), where it is forged into blanks. These blanks return to Tuttlingen, then travel on to Samsun (Türkiye). In Samsun, nearly all of the production takes place, machining, hand-finishing, assembly, until the instrument is (nearly) complete. From there, the (semi-)finished product goes back to Tuttlingen, where it is inspected, packaged, and stamped “Made in Germany.” Finally, it re-enters Türkiye and is sold to Turkish hospitals and surgeons.
The labor, skill, and knowledge embedded in Samsun vanish in this process. What remains visible is the final stamp.
From “Win-Win” to Poisoned Relations
As an interview partner traced the longer history of outsourcing between Germany and Pakistan: At first, it looked like a perfect arrangement. German firms in Tuttlingen reduced their production costs, while Pakistani workshops in Sialkot gained steady contracts. “At first both sides were happy,” he recalled. “It was win-win.”
But over time, the win-win began to unravel. Pakistan developed its own expertise and started to sell directly to global markets, particularly in low- and middle-income countries. “This win-win slowly began to poison itself,” he explained. What began as cooperation slowly shifted into competition.
Building “Paper Walls”
It was here that he introduced a powerful metaphor: “paper walls” (“kağıttan duvarlar”). As Pakistani firms in Sialkot grew more independent, European companies responded by tightening certification requirements and documentation processes.
“As they built those paper walls,” he said, “they created a structure that forced the goods to return to Germany, to be redistributed through German firms.”
These walls were not made of stone, but of regulations, audits, and standards. Yet they were just as effective in blocking independent access to global markets. They turned quality into a geopolitical weapon, ensuring that even when production took place elsewhere, recognition remained concentrated in Europe, especially in this case Germany.
Innovation, Recognition, and Survival
For Turkish firms in Samsun, the situation creates a double burden. On the one hand, they face the same asymmetry of recognition: doctors often prefer “Made in Germany,” even when the same instruments were produced locally. On the other hand, they are caught between Germany and Pakistan, unable to fully escape the shadow of either.
As one producer explained, the lack of recognition pushed them to take a radical decision: leave surgical instruments behind and move into high-tech medical devices. “It was a very heavy decision,” he recalled. “We could have gone bankrupt.” This transition reshaped the workforce gradually. Over the years, around 3,000 people worked at the company, many of whom later moved on, some preferring to stay with familiar routines, others joining competitors or starting their own businesses. Today, about 300 remain.
Innovation here was not just about new products. It was about survival, recognition, and the hope of escaping the double bind of circulation and paper walls.
Conclusion: Beyond Labels
This small glimpse from Samsun shows how epistemic asymmetry operates on multiple levels. It is in the surgeon’s preference for a German stamp. It is in the strange circulations of steel and instruments. And it is in the invisible barriers, the “paper walls,” that structure global markets. As one interviewee put it: “No matter how well you do, if the other side looks with prejudice, all your effort is wasted.”
STS often reminds us that innovation is situated. In Samsun, I saw how deeply this is true, how innovation flourishes in workshops and clusters that remain unrecognized in global hierarchies. Until the walls of recognition shift, much of this work will remain invisible, even when it is right in front of us.
We (Gülşah Başkavak and Melike Şahinol) are currently on the second day of our fieldwork for the MediCluster Project. Located approximately 700 kilometers from Istanbul, Samsun lies in the heart of the Black Sea region. Historically, this city has been a crossroads for trade, migration, and cultural exchange. Today, often referred to as “The Gateway of the Black Sea to the World”, Samsun serves as a key regional economic hub. Its port, industrial zones, and strong tradition of craftsmanship anchor its position in both national and international markets.
At 10:30 a.m., as arranged, we arrive at the factory. Upon entering, we are greeted by the deep, resonant hum of the machines. The air is heavy, hot, and humid. The wide workshop doors are fully open, allowing an occasional breeze from the Black Sea to carry the sounds of the machinery out into the open air.
Today, we started our one-on-one interviews with the masters. We listened as they shared their occupational journeys, providing valuable insights into their working practices, craft backgrounds, and production techniques. We learned about the intricate process behind making a surgical scissor: A task much more complex than it may seem at first glance. Each craft narrative serves as a testament to the meticulous manual labor that is central to the manufacturing of surgical instruments.
A single component of a surgical scissor during production, Samsun. Photo by Gülşah Başkavak, 14.08.2025.
In the workshops, the masters often combine techniques they learned decades ago with new materials and machinery. Our initial observations suggest that Samsun’s significance lies not only in its production capacity but also in the historical traces of knowledge and skills transferred from one craft to another over generations. We will keep listening to the masters. In the coming days, we plan to visit more factories, conduct detailed observations on-site, and carry out in-depth interviews.
By the end of the day, we arrived at Atakum Beach, where long stretches of golden sand extended toward the horizon. The sights and sounds of the day -the masters’ narratives, their voices, and the rhythm of their work- remained vivid in our minds. Under a slowly darkening sky, the Black Sea gently lapped its waves against the shore. On the horizon, the sun set, painting the water in shades of orange, pink, and violet. This second day of fieldwork not only satisfied our academic curiosity but also deepened our research interest in the rich culture of surgical craftsmanship in this city.
Atakum, Samsun. Photo by Gülşah Başkavak, 14.08.2025
Our first day of fieldwork we—Melike Şahinol and Gülşah Başkavak— started long before sunrise, at 4:30 a.m. yesterday (13.8.2025), when we set off towards Istanbul Airport. A short domestic flight brought us to Samsun by 9:00 a.m., where the Black Sea greeted us with its humid morning air. Knowing that our research would take us to multiple industrial sites scattered across the city and its surrounding districts, we picked up a rental car. Public transportation in these areas is limited, and the distances between companies can be considerable, especially in the industrial zones.
By 11:30 a.m., we arrived at our first destination – a large and well-established company in the medical instruments sector. We were welcomed warmly and began with an introductory conversation about the MediCluster project. We explained our aims: to understand the production practices of medical and surgical instruments in Samsun, and to do so from a sociological perspective. Our hosts expressed enthusiasm and even surprise that sociologists were taking an interest in what is often perceived purely as a technical or economic field. This openness and curiosity towards sociological research was encouraging and set a positive tone for the day.
As part of our introduction, we also addressed our data protection and ethical procedures. Our two-page information sheet – the result of our ethics application and consultation with the Max Weber Foundation’s data protection officer – seemed intimidating at first glance. I went through the document point-by-point, clarifying terms and explaining why each section was necessary. Still, the experience highlighted a practical challenge for qualitative fieldwork: lengthy, highly detailed consent forms can interrupt the natural flow of an interview. We have encountered similar concerns in discussions with other researchers and will need to find ways to meet ethical requirements without overburdening participants.
Around midday, we were invited to lunch by a company owner. Our conversation moved well beyond the manufacturing floor, touching on Türkiye’s flourishing beauty industry, its vast array of cosmetic procedures, and the country’s pioneering role in this field. We also discussed the broader medical sector, its reputation for quality, and its strong position in both national and international markets. These exchanges reminded us that medical device production in Samsun is embedded in a much wider medical and aesthetic landscape, where different industries intersect.
After lunch, we met our second key contact of the day – a board member whose father is the company’s owner. He welcomed us into the production facilities and led us on a detailed tour. The workshop was alive with activity: hundreds of different workpieces and blanks, some sourced from external suppliers, were neatly arranged at different stages of processing. We could follow the production chain step by step, from raw material to finely finished surgical instrument. The diversity of machinery was striking – CNC machines humming steadily, milling equipment shaping precise components, and other specialized tools at work.
The tour ended in the company’s small museum, where the family’s manufacturing history was on display. Here, we saw how production had shifted over generations – from weapons manufacturing in earlier decades, to other types of mechanical apparatus, and finally to medical devices and surgical instruments. One of the most memorable exhibits was a pair of tooth-extraction forceps made by the founders’ grandfathers in the 1940s. Our guide pointed to them and said, “These might have been our family’s very first medical instruments.” It was a powerful reminder of how technological expertise and craft traditions can evolve and transform over time.
Tooth-extraction forceps, Museum of Medical Instruments, Samsun, photo taken by Gülşah Başkavak, 13.8.2025
Following the museum visit, we sat down for our second interview of the day. Like the first, it was rich in detail and provided valuable insights into both production practices and the social dynamics of the industry. Before we left, we also discussed potential interviews with local craftspeople. Our hosts expressed a willingness to help us make these connections – a prospect we are already excited about as we continue our work in Samsun.
It was a long and eventful day, which we rounded off by enjoying some of Samsun’s culinary specialties: freshly baked börek, delicate Ottoman-style sarma, and nokul. Nokul is a classic Black Sea pastry—especially associated with Samsun (Bafra) and Sinop—made from a soft, yeasted dough rolled into coils or loaves with rich fillings such as walnuts and raisins with a touch of cinnamon, tahini and sugar, or even a savory minced-meat mixture. It’s typically enjoyed warm with tea and is as much a marker of local craft as it is a comfort food.
What happens when an industrial designer steps into a conversation on medical instrument manufacturing?
For our MediCluster team, it means opening new perspectives on how design thinking can intersect with regional production clusters, policy frameworks, and everyday practices in medical innovation.
On 25 June 2025, we invited Dr. Elmas Merve Özyurt for a workshop at Orient-Institut Istanbul. Özyurt is an industrial designer whose PhD research focuses on the medical device ecosystem in Türkiye. Özyurt shared valuable notes, many of which spoke to our research on surgical instrument manufacturing in Tuttlingen, Sialkot and Samsun and gave us constructive perspectives.
Workshop snapshot from our collaborative session. From left to right to left: Gülşah Başkavak, Elmas Merve Özyurt, Ayşe Berna Uçarol and Melike Şahinol
From Shells to Systems: Where Is Design in Medical Devices?
In her presentation, Dr. Özyurt pointed out that medical device design in Türkiye is often limited to superficial concerns, which she called “shell design”. However, trust, safety and usability are deeply linked to design decisions. This urged us to reflect on an important gap: many medical devices are not locally designed but locally manufactured. In this sense, design becomes not just an aesthetic issue, but an epistemic one. Who has the power to influence the function, touch, and safety of a device? And how do/can local actors gain credibility in a global market?
Design Is Not a Solo Act: Mapping the Network
Özyurt’s research includes interviews with stakeholders in the Turkish medical device industry, from companies to certification bodies and research institutions to end users. The literature map and fieldwork show that design does not operate in isolation. Design is shaped by policy incentives, R&D capacities, market expectations and dynamics within innovation clusters.
This aligns with our STS perspective in the MediCluster project, where we explore how innovation emerges from the entanglement of actors, practices, and infrastructures. In this process, design becomes a crucial junction where diverse forms of knowledge, values, and interests converge and sometimes collide.
Rethinking Clusters: The Value of Interdisciplinary Dialogue
Our discussion also highlighted regional differences. Istanbul-based firms generally put design on their agenda, while firms in Ankara are somewhat more attentive to the concepts of design and innovation. Özyurt characterizes the production in Samsun as predominantly rooted in craftsmanship and therefore excludes it from her study, which focuses specifically on medical devices rather than instruments. While this distinction is helpful for our research, it also raises new questions: What counts as design and who gets to decide? How is craftsmanship positioned in relation to formal design processes?
These questions also have policy relevance, especially when considering how to support SMEs, how to promote user-centered design, and how to build trust in locally produced medical devices.
Why This Matters
In MediCluster, we would like to make visible the hidden dimensions of medical production (craftsmanship, tacit knowledge, situated knowledge etc.). Özyurt’s contribution reminded us that design is part of this hidden layer. It is not simply a step in the production line but a site of negotiation, knowledge transfer, and identity formation.
Workshops like this help us build bridges between different fields: STS and industrial design, policy and practice, and academic research and the real world. They also underline the need for collaborative formats that allow questions rather than disciplines to drive the conversation.
What’s Next
As we move towards our next fieldwork phases, we are taking this dialog forward. How do/can regional innovation clusters foster inclusive design ecosystems? What roles can designers play in collaborative research? And how can we rethink the boundaries between design, engineering and craft?
These are not questions with simple answers, but they are the kind of questions that will drive MediCluster forward.
Every research project begins with mapping the existing knowledge – and that means diving into the literature. For our MediCluster project, this first step was both challenging and full of unexpected discoveries. We also conducted a literature review as a team in the first part of our project. Conducting a literature review as a team requires careful coordination to align everyone’s efforts and keep the process well-structured. Considering the scale of the MediCluster project, it was necessary to review a wide range of literature focusing on multiple areas and key concepts. The literature review process was demanding, but it allowed us to uncover valuable insights and sharpen our research focus.
While we were familiar with collaborative literature reviews from previous projects, this time we encountered a new dimension: artificial intelligence tools. We encountered new possibilities in almost every part of the literature review steps. These possibilities raised questions in our minds on many issues.
Should we use these tools?
If so, how should we use them?
How should we indicate that we used these tools?
Should we cite them? If so, how?
We discussed all these questions within our project team. We suspect that many researchers are currently grappling with similar questions. That’s why we want to share our experiences in this blog post – to contribute to this ongoing conversation.
First Encounter: Scopus AI
SCOPUS, one of the most well-known academic databases we consulted during our literature review, was a familiar environment for us. We identified key concepts related to the literature we were interested in, created various queries, and began analyzing the results. This time, however, we explored something new: SCOPUS AI (https://www.scopus.com/search/form.uri?display=basic#scopus-ai), which allowed us to ask questions in natural language and interact with the database in entirely different ways. One of our key research questions was: What role does craftsmanship play in the production of medical and surgical instruments? Normally, we would have spent considerable time constructing complex keyword queries to retrieve relevant academic studies addressing this topic. With SCOPUS AI, we could simply input this question in natural language – and the system generated an overview of related publications and insights within seconds.
Scopus AI screen shot
It reports not only the relevant database records but also provides a natural language summary generated from these records, highlighting the core concepts and themes of the studies and the prominent researchers involved. This was impressive; however, it immediately raised two concerns: whether we had written the most complete and accurate prompt, and whether the results produced for us represented a comprehensive and balanced view of the literature – that is, which studies were included and why, which were excluded and why, and how limited the range of cited literature was within the AI-generated summaries. While the visualizations produced by SCOPUS AI, focusing on different types of maps and concepts, are functional, we must not forget that the literature on which they are based is quantitatively quite limited. Moreover, how this selection is made is not entirely transparent.
What mattered most to us was the process of discovering the literature. Often, the keywords we use to search the literature evolve and change during the search process as we encounter both quantitative and qualitative results, and the final set of results we obtain represents the sum of this organic development. We realized that we valued this process itself, both in terms of learning and research. Nevertheless, we were unsure whether the set of results obtained in response to our question would be sufficient for our purposes. For this reason, we chose not to rely solely on SCOPUS AI. Despite these concerns, we found that the results produced by this tool were also useful. In our case, SCOPUS AI served as a preparatory phase within the literature review process. We asked our questions, examined the answers, took notes, and then transformed this output into an organic input for our systematic review.
Second Encounter: ChatGPT DeepResearch
Our encounter with DeepResearch (https://chatgpt.com), a feature of OpenAI’s language model ChatGPT, was slightly more striking. ChatGPT describes the DeepResearch feature as follows:
DeepResearch is an AI-powered in-depth literature search tool developed for researchers, academics, and content creators. This feature goes beyond traditional search engines, scanning numerous scientific articles, book chapters, databases, and other academic sources to provide concise, meaningful, and sourced information.
When you submit your literature review question in natural language to ChatGPT DeepResearch, it accepts the input and asks follow-up questions to further clarify the topic. The screenshot below shows an example of the questions the tool asks you.
ChatGPT Screen shot
When you answer these questions, it prepares an output tailored to your request. This output, presented in natural language and the formal style we aim for, is based on academic and official sources, which it also cites. The process is straightforward: we start with a literature review question and ultimately arrive at an output that is comparable in quantity and quality to a manually written text. Does this mean all our efforts are redundant? The answer is clear: of course not.
A literature review is a text based on concrete findings from existing literature, constructed and finalized within the subjective framework of the researcher’s personal choices and prior knowledge. This was the most prominent topic in our discussions within the project team. Although the DeepResearch output is comprehensive, formally appropriate, and based on concrete studies, we would not have constructed this text in exactly the same way.
A related, slightly more complex question arises: Which of these texts is of higher quality – the one we prepared or the DeepResearch output? This is a layered discussion. From our experience, we maintained a certain distance from the DeepResearch output. However, as we analyzed the text, we discovered themes, concepts, and documents that had not occurred to us (often reports not found in academic databases but that nevertheless contribute to the quality of the work). This allowed us to access the sources of different discussions and incorporate them into our own texts, thereby enriching our work. At the same time, we noticed that the DeepResearch texts sometimes strayed from the core of the discussion and included certain repetitive sections, which we found less useful. At this stage, we focused on a different approach to using DeepResearch: an instrumental use. In this method, we fed the same problem into DeepResearch, along with the publications we had compiled ourselves, and requested a literature summary based solely on these publications. We even specified the qualitative criteria that the literature summary should follow. We found that the literature produced in this manner was largely similar to the literature we had prepared ourselves. This output involved cross-checking whether the cited texts met the necessary criteria and, at times, revising repetitive sections even if their overall volume decreased. In effect, this output proved largely successful after human intervention.
We then discussed, within our project team, the status of this kind of use. We had scanned the literature and created our publication pool. We also specified to ChatGPT the criteria and quality for the text to be prepared from all the available publications. As a result, ChatGPT functioned more like an editor than a contributor of ideas. We subsequently reviewed the resulting text both factually and stylistically. The preferences, references, and flow of the text were structured according to our guidelines. In this case, should we refer to this text as AI-assisted production?
Remembering the Fundamental Principle: Transparency and Ethics
An important dimension that emerged during our engagement with AI tools was the question of explainability. While tools like DeepResearch provided us with structured and seemingly accurate literature summaries, we often found ourselves wondering how exactly these results were generated. What sources were prioritized? Which patterns or associations led to the selection of certain themes? This experience pointed us toward the field of Explainable AI (XAI), which advocates for transparency in how AI systems make decisions. In the context of academic research, XAI is particularly crucial, as it aligns with the core principles of verifiability, traceability, and accountability. Without understanding the reasoning behind an AI-generated output, it becomes difficult to critically engage with or ethically rely on the results.
We have provided a straightforward answer to this question and to the various questions that arose throughout the process, after lengthy discussions. Above all, a researcher must be transparent and ethical. For this reason, we recorded the levels of artificial intelligence support we have received in the relevant sections of every document we prepared, regardless of whether or not these documents will eventually be made public. We also make sure to record every stage of our process, including grammar and spelling checks, in the final text. In doing so, we believe we have fulfilled our ethical responsibility and taken a good-faith step to address potential issues from the outset.
Conclusion: Research as a Craft
Through this project, we explored the relevant literature and gained new experience in using artificial intelligence in scientific research. We observed that the discussions within our project team regarding this experience provided a valuable opportunity to evaluate our ethical dilemmas and concerns about quality from various perspectives.
At the same time, our literature review procedures have clearly evolved. We now begin the process by consulting tools such as Scopus AI and DeepResearch. These outputs serve as exploratory searches that enrich and update our research plan before moving on to the traditional search step. Today, we continue to conduct our comprehensive search with a holistic perspective. Although we cannot know what tomorrow will bring, we enrich our outputs with AI-based recommendation tools, review them multiple times, and make decisions continuously throughout the process. This process shapes us as academic craftsmen who can make new decisions in response to changing circumstances. Indeed, Pye (1968), whom we encountered in the literature we reviewed for this project, defines the craftsman as someone who makes new decisions at every moment while working. In his view, craftsmanship is not merely manual labor; it is a mental process that involves constant decision-making, intuition, and attention. This makes it not only a physical but also a cognitive activity. Just as the literature review is more than manual labor, we, as researchers, engage fully with its cognitive aspects, carrying the weight of our accumulated knowledge and responsibilities, while also embracing the advantages and opportunities provided by artificial intelligence.
Our experiences show that navigating AI-supported literature reviews is itself a socio-technical practice – one that calls for critical reflection, transparency, and an ongoing dialogue within the research community.
On May 7, 2025, our MediCluster team came together at Orient-Institut Istanbul for a workshop in order to joint observation and methodological reflextion. For this reason, we watched short video sequences from three medical manufacturing hubs – Tuttlingen (Germany), Sialkot (Pakistan) and Samsun (Türkiye). But these were not just factory tours. Rather than analyzing results, our goal was to explore what we might encounter in the field and how to approach it empirically. We ask: How can we, beyond interviews, access the embodied knowledge of craftsmanship through observation and video? What kinds of gestures, tools, routines, etc. reveal the tacit dimensions of producing surgical instruments? More than a video analysis session, it was a shared exercise in getting ready for fieldwork. It helped us train our gaze of the subtle, often invisible forms of knowledge that emerge in the everyday making of medical instruments.
Why Video? Why Now?
Medical instrument production is a process full of subtleties. This process, which has developed historically, spans from from human hands to robotic systems and AI-driven tools. During production, a range of elements, such as bodily techniques, the use of materials, and the environment in which production takes place tell us something meaningful. These dimensions are often tacit, situated and embodied.
Video enables us to slow down and notice these moments. The videos we watched were mostly produced for marketing or promotional purposes, offering curated views of manufacturing in Tuttlingen (Germany), Sialkot (Pakistan), and Samsun (Turkey). Our goal was not to critique them as such, but to explore what they could show us: What kinds of environments are these instruments made in? What kinds of labor are shown—or hidden?What becomes visible across different cultural and industrial contexts, and how might we interpret these signals?
Watching together allowed us to begin building a shared research gaze. The session became a starting point: a way to orient ourselves toward the field, to raise questions about visibility and invisibility, and to reflect on how we might approach craftsmanship methodologically in diverse settings.
Workshop snapshot from our collaborative session. From left to right to left: Melike Şahinol, Gülşah Başkavak and Ayşe Berna Uçarol.
Seeing Craft in Motion: How We Observed and What We Observed
Our session started with a common framing. We reminded ourselves of the focus of the project: to compare how medical innovation emerges through production in different clusters. We then introduced video analysis as a method based on sociological videography and praxeological thinking. At this stage we made use of Knoblauch’s (2014) videography perspective and Bohnsack’s (2009) methods of analysis.
We then watched. Short clips. One from each cluster. For each, we paused and reflected:
In Tuttlingen, we saw high levels of precision and mechanization—but also clear, routinized bodily techniques that suggest long-term training. A video featured a highly professionalized company working closely with hospitals, highlighting how surgical instrument manufacturing here is deeply embedded in clinical practice and subject to strict standards and specialization. In one of the Tuttlingen videos, a surgical instrument maker who had been working in the field for decades remarked that he “knows exactly how to perform a knee operation.” Of course, he’s not a surgeon—but his statement speaks volumes. It points to the depth of practical knowledge accumulated over years of crafting and refining tools: a kind of situated expertise shaped by close alignment with surgical procedures, clinical contexts, and tacit standards of quality. (see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZztgU6Gs8Wk , https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jyfmN2I5R_8&t=62s ; access date: 03 May 2025)
In Sialkot, we observed a contrast between two production settings. One clip showed a relatively modern facility, while the other depicted a much more basic environment: a workshop in a warehouse-like space, where grinding work was carried out under visibly challenging and chaotic conditions. Dust, noise, and improvisation shaped the scene, pointing to a different mode of production—one where craft persists despite infrastructural constraints (see https://www.youtube.com/shorts/_3J97R9UBTc , https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1tUuONuiAdY ; access date: 03 May 2025)
In Samsun, we noticed hybrid patterns. One video featured a master craftsman recounting how he first got involved in instrument making—when a surgeon once asked him to repair a tool. That moment marked the beginning of a hands-on learning process, shaped by close collaboration and practical needs. Another video showed a more formalized path: a training program for surgical instrument makers closely tied to a company and a university, reflecting a more institutionalized model of skill development (see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TgOpdPQHkQw&t=60s, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6fST-_yTUE ; access date: 03 May 2025).
Beyond the Frame: What We Learned
The real value of the session came not from the videos alone, but from the conversations they sparked. We asked difficult, open-ended questions:
What kinds of tacit knowledge are visible in each cluster and what remains hidden?
How do spatial arrangements and tool usage reflect broader organizational cultures?
Can “innovation” mean something different when driven by surgeon demands, repairability, or customer customization?
These questions led us to reflect on deeper theoretical issues such as the agency of materials (inspired by new materialist thinkers such as Jane Bennett and Karen Barad) and the role of interpersonal interactions – master-apprentice dynamics, informal education or peer correction – in knowledge transmission. Some questions arose in our minds: Are we seeing innovation or just adaptation? Another of us wondered whether standardization, while enabling global reach, may also erase valuable forms of localized, context-sensitive knowledge. These were not debates to be resolved, but routes to be followed—directions for the next stage of our research.
The Bigger Picture: Why It Matters
Medical devices are standardized globally, but their production is different. In Sialkot, tools are tailored to customer needs. In Tuttlingen, systems are optimized for scale and regulation. In Samsun, hybrid applications are emerging. What unites them is not uniformity, but craft as a living method.
And we realized that video is one of the few ways we can see this craft not as a nostalgic idea, but as a site of technical innovation, human ingenuity and socio-material entanglement.
This workshop made one thing clear: understanding innovation in medical manufacturing is not just about policies or patents. It is about watching the movement of hands, the exchange of tools, the flow of information and learning to recognize the small actions that hold systems together.
What’s Next
We are currently preparing our report on our first work package. This report is based on a comprehensive literature review. These workshops are being organized to strengthen the outputs of this package. We will start collecting field data for our study in the coming period. This workshop provided valuable insights and served as an important step in preparing for fieldwork. As we move from watching to doing fieldwork, we carry with us not just questions, but a sharpened sense of what to look for. Ultimately, what we learned from watching together is that seeing is never neutral—it’s already the beginning of analysis.
References
Bohnsack, R. (2009). The Interpretation of Pictures and the Documentary Method. In: Historical Social Research / Historische Sozialforschung , 2009, Vol. 34, No. 2 (128)
Discover Pakistan. (2022, Aug 22). Amazing Manufacturing Process of Surgical Instruments Inside Factory | ASMR [Video]. Youtube.
Kayseradar. (2024 May 28). Cerrahi Alet Ustası. [Video]. Youtube.
Knoblauch, H., et. al. (2014). Video Analysis and Videography. In: U. Flick (Ed.) The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Data Analysis, London: Sage, 435–449
Germany Trade & Invest (GTAI). (2020, Nov 12). HEALTH MADE IN GERMANY: Medical Technology [Video]. Youtube.
Show Ana Haber. (2023, Dec 19).Bu lise, cerrahi alet üretimine nitelikli elaman yetiştiriyor! [Video]. Youtube.
Technik auf dem neuesten Stand. (2015, Nov 1). Auf Messers Schneide – Tuttlingens Welt der chirurgischen Instrumente, Medizintechnik, Implantate [Video]. Youtube.
Rather than separating artifacts or machines from the people who make them, MediCluster explores how innovation emerges from the entanglement of craft practices, technical standards, and regional knowledge cultures.
Our research project investigates how surgical instruments are manufactured in three very different contexts: Tuttlingen (Germany), Sialkot (Pakistan), and Samsun (Türkiye). While these regions differ in geography and economic conditions, they share a strong reliance on craft-based production – and on forms of knowledge that are often implicit, embodied, and overlooked.
On April 30, 2025, our team held its first research workshop at the Orient-Institut Istanbul. But this was not your typical academic meeting. Instead of presenting finalized findings, we did something different: we collectively explored how knowledge—especially the situated, tacit, and embodied kind—shapes medical instrument manufacturing across our clusters.
Reading Each Other’s Work: A Method of Reflexive Collaboration
As part of Work Package 1 (WP1), each team member had already conducted a systematic literature review focusing on a distinct topic: innovation policies in peripheral regions, the dynamics of situated and tacit knowledge in craft practices, regional innovation systems and cluster theories, and the concept of craftsmanship inside and outside of medicine.
The workshop was designed as a space to discuss and synthesize these findings. Rather than presenting these reviews in isolation, we adopted an integrative and dialogical approach. Each team member read the others’ work and formulated a set of critical questions that were then discussed in a structured, time-boxed format during the workshop. This shift from individual reporting to collective interrogation did more than enhance understanding—it fostered a collaborative mode of thinking in which theory, method, and context could resonate across disciplinary and regional boundaries.
Our approach served multiple purposes:
to explore how theoretical concepts such as “situated knowledge” or “regional innovation” travel and transform across geographical, institutional, and epistemic contexts;
to extract methodological insights that could inform our future ethnographic fieldwork in the three clusters;
and to uncover latent blind spots and conceptual tensions—particularly those arising from Global North–South asymmetries, the divide between codified and tacit knowledge, and the complex role of digitalization in reshaping craft and expertise.
Through this collective reading and questioning process, we not only sharpened our analytical framework but also began building a shared vocabulary that will support our collaborative work moving forward.
Workshop snapshot from our collaborative session. From left to right to left: Uğur Kocager, Ayşe Berna Uçarol, Gülşah Başkavak and Melike Şahinol.
A Workshop Framed by Questions, Not Just Answers
Rather than organizing our workshop around pre-prepared presentations, we framed it around questions—questions that emerged through close readings of each other’s literature reviews, and that were meant not only to clarify but to provoke, connect, and challenge. Each participant selected two to three of the most resonant or difficult questions posed by their peers and responded to them in a structured, time-boxed session.
The questions covered a wide spectrum—from theoretical concerns to methodological tensions and empirical puzzles. For example:
How do we analyze craft when production is increasingly mediated by CAD software, robotics, or simulation environments?
Can Samsun, as a late-emerging cluster, develop a “third way” that avoids simply replicating Global North models or being absorbed into low-cost manufacturing logics?
How does knowledge travel from a family-owned workshop in Sialkot to international hospitals—and what tacit elements of this knowledge get lost in translation?
This format helped us move beyond the linearity of individual arguments and toward a shared conceptual framework. It made visible how our respective topics intersect, diverge, and enrich one another—especially around key themes like:
the role of embodied and situated knowledge in innovation,
the epistemic hierarchies embedded in North–South dynamics,
and the challenge of theorizing digital transformation without erasing material practices.
By centering the workshop on reciprocal questioning, we created a research space that was both analytically rigorous and genuinely collaborative—an approach that reflects the spirit of MediCluster itself.
Resonance and Reflection: What We Learned
Three key insights emerged:
Craft is knowledge. It is not merely a method of production but a dynamic interplay of materials, bodies, and social relations. In our project, understanding craft means taking seriously the lived knowledge of workers, not just the devices they help produce.
Clusters are not just economic structures. They are cultural and epistemic formations, shaped by historical legacies, family models, and regional politics. Recognizing these dimensions helps us move beyond the typical Global North–South dichotomy.
Interdisciplinary dialogue needs structure. Our format—reading each other’s reviews, asking questions, discussing time-boxed—helped generate clarity, foster trust, and avoid disciplinary silos. It also laid the groundwork for co-authored publications and the upcoming WP1 interim report.
Why It Matters (Beyond Academia)
Surgical instruments touch millions of lives—but the knowledge cultures behind them remain largely invisible. By bringing this hidden dimension into focus, we hope to inform not only academic debates but also policy decisions around health innovation, labor, and regional development.
Our workshop didn’t just produce results—it produced vocabulary, connections, and shared curiosity. It showed us that science communication begins within the team, when we take time to ask each other the right questions.
What’s Next
We’re currently drafting our interim report for Work Package 1 (WP1.R1), including contributions from all literature reviews. Two co-authored academic articles are in development, and our next meeting is scheduled for May 7, where we’ll discuss the draft report and conceptual architecture.
This is just the beginning—but thanks to this workshop, we now have a clearer map of where we’re headed. And more importantly, why it matters.
We are pleased to share that Dr. Gülşah Başkavak, a valued member of our research team, has been accepted to present her work at the Turkologentag 2025 – Fifth European Convention on Turkic, Ottoman and Turkish Studies, to be held at Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz, Germany from 18-20 September 2025.
Dr. Başkavak’s paper, entitled “From Scalpel to Robotic Surgery: Technological Change, Healthcare, and Surgeons in Turkey”provides a sociological analysis of how robotic and AI-driven innovations are reshaping surgical practices in Turkey. It explores the transformation of surgeons’ skills, professional autonomy, and operating room dynamics, while critically engaging with broader implications for healthcare infrastructure and patient perception.
Turkologentag stands as one of the premier academic gatherings in the field, convened triennially under the auspices of the Society for Turkic, Ottoman and Turkish Studies (GTOT). The conference convenes leading scholars from across Europe and beyond, serving as fostering interdisciplinary dialogue. It facilitates the dissemination of cutting-edge research across a broad spectrum of disciplines, including Ottoman and Turkish Studies, cultural studies, art history, musicology, women and gender studies, sociology, migration studies, social anthropology, digital humanities, language acquisition, language teaching, and multilingualism.
We congratulate Dr. Başkavak on this well-deserved recognition and look forward to the insights her presentation will bring to Sociology and the growing field of STS (Science and Technology Studies) within the context of Turkey.
Stay tuned for updates from the conference this September!
We are excited to announce that our research project MediCluster finally has its very own logo!
Logo of the MediCluster research project.
A special thank-you goes to 11ftahead for designing our new logo. Their creative approach has perfectly captured MediCluster’s mission to illuminate the complex interactions between local manufacturing, global value chains, and regional innovation cultures.
We hope this new visual identity will make MediCluster’s goals and findings more recognizable to both our academic colleagues and the broader public. Stay tuned for more insights, publications, and behind-the-scenes perspectives from our ongoing research!
4S (Society for Social Studies of Science), one of the world’s leading conferences on STS (Science and Technology Studies / Science, Technology, and Society, https://www.4sonline.org/what_is_4s.php), will take place in Seattle this year. Within the scope of our project, Dr. Melike Şahinol and Dr. Gülşah Başkavak have been accepted to present their papers at this prestigious conference! Şahinol and Başkavak will present the paper titled “Bridging Craft and Innovation: Surgical Instrument Manufacturing Between the Global South and North” at the conference, which will take place on September 3 – 6, 2025.
A paper challenging regional considerations from an STS perspective
Within the scope of the DFG-funded project MediCluster, “Bridging Craft and Innovation: Surgical Instrument Manufacturing Between the Global South and North” focuses on the manufacturing centers of medical instruments. Emphasizing knowledge, labor and technology interacting between the global North and South, the paper examines the clusters of Tutlingen (Germany), Sialkot (Pakistan) and Samsun (Türkiye) in their interrelatedness. In this way, the study aims to overcome the limitations of a regional perspective and attempts to explore the dynamic movement of expertise, trade and technology on a global scale. By focusing on different geographical clusters globally, the study makes an assessment based on the STS perspective between separate innovation clusters.
About the 4S 2025 Seattle Conference
The 4S 2025 Conference stands out as one of the most prestigious events in STS. Bringing together academics, researchers and experts from around the world every year, this conference provides an important platform for the most up-to-date discussions in the field of STS.
This year’s conference, which will be held in Seattle, themed “Reverberations” (https://4sonline.org/about_the_conference_seattle.php) invites participants to explore how science and technology echo across time, space, and cultures. The concept of reverberation—whether as seismic waves, cultural echoes, or transcontinental impacts—offers a rich framework for examining the interconnectedness of past and present, local and global, and material and symbolic practices. From Indigenous resistance in the Seattle region to the global ripple effects of technological innovations, the theme encourages a deep engagement with the layered histories and futures of STS.
Our researchers Şahinol & Başkavak will present a paper (see below) that resonates with this theme by examining the relationship between global power balances and local production practices in the context of medical technologies. By focusing on how global norms and local innovations reverberate through medical production processes, our contribution aims to shed light on the complex interplay of politics, economics, and technology in shaping healthcare systems worldwide.
“Bridging Craft and Innovation: Surgical Instrument Manufacturing Between the Global South and North”
Manufacturing practices of medical instruments are shaped by transnational networks of knowledge, labor, and technology that link regions across the Global South and North. While industrial automation increasingly dominates medical manufacturing, craft-based expertise remains essential for precision surgical tools. This paper examines the interconnected manufacturing clusters of Tuttlingen (Germany), Sialkot (Pakistan), and Samsun (Türkiye), exploring how knowledge, labor, and materials circulate across these sites and contribute to the evolving landscape of medical instrument production.
By situating manufacturing practices of surgical instruments within an oceanic framework, this study challenges rigid territorial lenses that separate “Asian,” or “Middle Eastern” studies. Instead, it highlights the dynamic movement of expertise, trade, and technology across the Indian Ocean and beyond. The concept of echoes and extensions provides a perspective to analyze how historical craft traditions resonate across time (echo) and adapt to changing global production networks (extend). Türkiye’s position between the Global South and North offers a compelling case to investigate how globalized medical manufacturing shapes and is shaped by regional innovation cultures, value chains, and geopolitical contexts.
By bringing manufacturing practices of medical instruments in globally different situated innovation clusters into a transregional frame, this contribution expands STS discussions on medical technologies beyond national or continental categories. It critically engages with decolonial and transnational STS perspectives, emphasizing the need to rethink established narratives of innovation, expertise, and technological development in the global medical technology landscape.