Digital resources in the Social Sciences and Humanities OpenEdition Our platforms OpenEdition Books OpenEdition Journals Hypotheses Calenda Libraries OpenEdition Freemium Follow us

Crafting Technotopias: Insights from the STS Türkiye 2025 Conference

This blog post offers a reflection on our contribution to the STS Türkiye 2025 Conference, highlighting how the MediCluster project engaged with discussions on craft, design, and global circulations within surgical instrument manufacturing.

Context: STS Türkiye 2025 Conference

The STS Türkiye 2025 Conference, “Technotopias – Imaginaries of the Past, Present, and Future,” took place on November 6–7, 2025, at HECAS – Hekimbaşı Center for Advanced Studies in Istanbul. Guided by the theme Technotopias – Imaginaries of the Past, Present, and Future, STS Türkiye 2025 gathered researchers from across disciplines to reflect on how science and technology shape — and are shaped by — socialtechnical imaginaries and everyday worlds.

The image is a poster for the STS Turkey 2025: Technotopias, Past, Present, and Future Imaginations conference, jointly organized by STS Turkey and HECAS. The image includes the conference location and date.
STS Türkiye 2025 Conference Poster

In the opening speech, Melike Şahinol invited us to rethink technotopias as lived, situated formations rooted in material practices and embodied expertise. This perspective framed many of the conversations that followed.

Melike Şahinol is presenting the STS Türkiye 2025 conference opening speech at HECAS

As part of the conference program, the panel “Craft, Design, and the Body”, chaired by Melike Şahinol, featured a talk by the MediCluster researchers, sharing insights from our ongoing research on global surgical instrument manufacturing.

The Panel Context

Our panel “Craft, Design, and the Body” brought together complementary perspectives on how craft, design, and technology shape sociotechnical futures. We opened the session with our joint presentation, which introduced findings from the Samsun fieldwork and examined surgical instrument production as part of globally circulating sociotechnical craftscapes.

This was followed by Dijan Özkurt’s contribution, exploring the Istanbul Design Biennial as a site where design functions as a relational practice and an infrastructure for producing public imaginaries. The final presentation by Burak Öztürk reflected on symbiotic art and the forms of human–machine co-agency that emerge in creative processes, prompting a rethinking of embodiment and aesthetic experience.

Together, the panel’s contributions demonstrated that craft, design, and innovation are deeply intertwined practices. Each talk highlighted how future imaginaries are shaped through material engagements, embodied expertise, and relational forms of making – reinforcing the conference theme of technotopias as lived and continuously negotiated formations.

Our Contribution: Local Craft Practices in Samsun

Building on this broader conversation, our presentation introduced the MediCluster Project and focused specifically on the Samsun field site – one of the three interconnected production clusters we examine alongside Tuttlingen and Sialkot. Drawing on completed fieldwork, including in-depth interviews and video ethnography conducted across enterprises of different scales, we traced how surgical instrument production in Samsun forms part of wider sociotechnical craftscapes shaped by embodied knowledge, material practices, and global circulations.

Gülşah Başkavak presenting “Reshaping the Future through the Heritage of Craftsmanship: The Sociotechnical Landscapes of Local Craft Practices in Samsun,” STS Türkiye 2025, HECAS, Istanbul

A key point of discussion was how instruments, ideas, and expertise move across regions, shaping technological geographies – the technotopias – of the future. By situating local craft practices within these global flows, we highlighted how Samsun’s production culture contributes to, and is transformed by, the circulations of skills, materials, and standards.

Reflections from the Discussion: “Sociotechnical Craftscapes” and the “Oceanic Perspective”

The discussion began by emphasizing the global significance of surgical instruments. Within this framework, the vital impact of surgical tools on living beings, the coexistence of automation and manual skill in production processes, and the various forms of specialization within global supply chains were addressed.

In the later stages of the session, the conceptual frameworks of “sociotechnical craftscapes” and the “oceanic perspective” (Şahinol, 2025) provided the theoretical grounding for the discussion. Through these concepts, the group highlighted that sociotechnical craftscapes are not neutral spaces but are shaped by historically rooted global inequalities. They show how imaginaries of medical technologies emerge within uneven conditions of recognition, mobility, and access to resources — and how local practices both navigate and challenge these asymmetries.

Şahinol emphasized that the oceanic perspective serves to unsettle rigid binaries such as center–periphery and North–South without ignoring their material effects. Rather than assuming free circulation, it draws attention to the frictions, blockages, and power relations that structure how knowledge, materials, and standards move across regions. As Şahinol noted, this perspective does not replace North–South or coloniality debates but deepens them by revealing how colonial power is enacted, redistributed, and contested through circulation itself — affecting actors across regions, from small manufacturers in so-called centers who struggle under tightening EU regulatory regimes to producers in places like Türkiye who experience these same regimes as paper walls that limit access and recognition. This approach makes it possible to see how global inequalities are reproduced through circulation — and how places like Samsun negotiate space within these uneven landscapes.

Shaping the Future Through the Traces of the Past: Samsun’s Craft Heritage

Samsun’s longstanding craft heritage illustrates how the future of medical instrument production emerges through the continuous interplay of past knowledge, present practices, and future aspirations. Historical craft traditions remain embedded in everyday production routines and influence contemporary political, economic, and technological decisions. Technotopias – the spaces of future technologies – take shape precisely in these flows, gestures, and fine-tuned adjustments of craft.

From the Field: Technotopias of Craft

  • Tacit Knowledge – At the heart of craftsmanship lies a form of knowledge that cannot be fully expressed in words or writing — tacit knowledge. A master cannot easily explain how they do their work but can demonstrate it in practice. This is a bodily form of knowing, learned through the senses — touch, sight, hearing, even smell. Alongside written ISO standards, there also exist “felt standards” — the sensory protocols of the craftsman.
  • Material Regimes – Material regimes constitute the invisible strategic framework of production. The quality of steel, the order of processing, and the surface finish determine not only the technical value of a product but also its status and the markets it can access. In Samsun, masters do more than shape steel; they shape its place within the global market.
  • Circulation and Recognition – Brand, origin, and expertise do not always align — there is a constant tension between them. Certification processes build “paper walls” that restrict the circulation of knowledge and labor. Yet, user-centered design and the sensory sensibility of craftsmanship serve as critical junctions that guide the direction of future technotopias.

From the Field: The Co-Production Matrix — Reading the Future of Craftsmanship

Analyzing the Samsun fieldwork through the lens of a co-production matrix reveals how norms, local practices, and material possibilities continuously shape one another. The “fine-tuning” gestures and sequences of operations observed in workshops already carry traces of the future within the present.

The co-production matrix is not merely a technical matter; it is also intertwined with questions of recognition and global positioning. Smart incentive policies that consider Samsun’s historical craft heritage and its layered traditions could negotiate between local knowledge and global quality regimes — paving the way for a more just and sustainable future of production.

The image features a diagram showing three boxes interacting in two directions. The first box contains Global Norms, the second box contains Local Practices, and the third box contains Material Possibilities.
Source: “Co-Production Matrix and Trajectories,“ in Şahinol, M., Başkavak, G., and Uçarol, A. B. (2025).

Future Orientation

The discussion reaffirmed that craftsmanship is not a remnant of the past, but a vital, living knowledge practice shaping the production worlds of tomorrow. With upcoming fieldwork in Tuttlingen and Sialkot, we aim to deepen our comparative understanding of how different clusters specialize within global surgical instrument supply chains. The thoughtful questions from the audience provided valuable impulses for the next phases of our research.

STS Türkiye 2025 conference snapshot, HECAS, Istanbul. From left to right: Ayşe Berna Uçarol, Gülşah Başkavak, Melike Şahinol
STS Türkiye 2025 conference snapshot, HECAS, Istanbul. From left to right: Ayşe Berna Uçarol, Gülşah Başkavak, Melike Şahinol

A Gathering on the Multiple Ontologies of Steel: A Workshop on Circulation, Knowledge, and Socio-Technical Imaginaries

The workshop titled “Multiple Ontologies of Steel: Circulation, Knowledge and Socio-Technical Imaginaries,” held on 27 November 2025 at the Orient-Institut Istanbul as part of the MediCluster project, created a productive space for rethinking both the production processes of steel and its multi-layered circulations within medical and surgical instrument manufacturing through an STS perspective. The invited expert was researcher Dursun Baş (IPC), whose work focuses on climate policy, carbon transitions, and transformations in the steel sector. His ongoing research is closely aligned with the “Türkiye Çelik Sektörünün Karbonsuzlaştırılması (Decarbonization of Türkiye’s Steel Sector)” project conducted at the Istanbul Policy Center: https://ipc.sabanciuniv.edu/tr/iklimprojeleri.

The workshop aimed to revisit questions that the MediCluster team — Melike Şahinol, Gülşah Başkavak, Ayşe Berna Uçarol and Uğur Kocager — encountered during fieldwork, through the material, political and epistemic dimensions of steel.

A visual poster promoting a workshop on Steel held at the Orient Institute in Istanbul on November 27, 2025.
Workshop flyer “Çeliğin Çoklu Ontolojileri” (MediCluster)

An Introduction to Steel: Material, Process and Geographies

The session opened with a brief presentation by Melike Şahinol, who revisited the project’s central focus. Drawing on conversations that stretch from the embodied know-how of master craftsmen in Samsun to the assessments of materials engineers in Germany, Şahinol outlined several points that stand out across these different perspectives.

Following this, Dursun Baş provided an overview of steel production not only in technical terms but also through its economic and political dimensions. He noted that steel is an alloy of iron and carbon, a “material multiplicity” that functions less as a single substance and more as a structure that can take on numerous combinations. As he put it,

“It is like following a recipe.”

Building on this foundational description, Baş offered a broader assessment of global and Turkish markets, as well as the distinctions between primary and secondary steel production and their implications.

When these insights are considered alongside MediCluster’s field observations, an evident tension emerges: countries with strong secondary production, such as Türkiye and Pakistan, still need to import high-quality stainless steel for the medical and surgical instrument sector.

Samsun, Sialkot, and Tuttlingen: A Transnational Flow of Material and Knowledge

One of the most engaging discussions of the workshop centered on how surgical instrument manufacturers in Samsun access high-quality steel.

Baş responded unequivocally:

“No one in Türkiye produces steel of that grade. Each product group requires different types of stainless steel. Manufacturers must import the material they need.”

This challenge connects directly to one of MediCluster’s key analytical frames: the asymmetric circulations of knowledge, materials, and labor.

Such circulations generate a double invisibility, both material and epistemic. Although Sialkot and Samsun form critical nodes in the global surgical instrument chain, they often remain obscured. Surgeons’ preference for “German-made” instruments reflects networks of trust, prestige, branding and epistemic authority rather than intrinsic material differences.

For this reason, Şahinol introduced the importance of an “oceanic perspective.” In this view, steel is not merely a material. It is a circulating, transforming and trace-bearing entity that gathers different meanings as it moves across geographies.

Socio-Technical Layers of Steel: Knowledge, Power and Effect

Three conceptual themes emerged prominently during the workshop:

    1. Epistemic Asymmetry

The informational history of a surgical instrument is frequently attributed to Germany. In reality, however, the tacit skills of craftsmen in Samsun, the technical labor in Sialkot and numerous local micro-innovations play a decisive role. Yet these contributions are seldom patented, named or formally recognized.

    1. The Invisibility of Micro-Innovations

Field research consistently reveals that companies, skilled artisans and engineers produce many small-scale technical improvements. These do not enter formal documentation systems such as patents or design registries. As a result, the knowledge they generate cannot be traced, which creates an epistemological problem beyond an economic one.

    1. The Multiple Ontologies of Material

Steel assumes different forms of being throughout its production and use:

  • For engineers, it is a technical alloy.
  • For manufacturers, it is a cost element.
  • For craftsmen, it is a material sensed through resistance and texture.
  • For exporters, it is a marker of quality.
  • For surgeons, it is a matter of precision and trust.
  • For patients, it becomes an invisible carrier of healing.

A Research Possibility: Tracing the Journey of Stainless Steel in Türkiye

One of Baş’s suggestions offers a strong starting point for a future collaboration: tracing the stainless-steel chain from its supplier to its arrival in Samsun.

Such a study would align closely with MediCluster’s interest in the socio-technical entanglements of material flows. Following this chain would illuminate not only the movements of material, but also:

  • the structure of trust relations,
  • the actors who define knowledge transfer,
  • the stages at which production becomes visible or hegemonic,
  • and the parts of the chain that are rendered invisible.
The image shows four people sitting around a table. It's an academic study environment. The table is lined with a computer, paper, pens, and various snacks. From left to right, Gülşah Başkavak, Melike Şahinol, Dursun Baş, and Ayşe Berna Uçarol are pictured.
Workshop snapshot “Çeliğin Çoklu Ontolojileri“, Orient-Institut Istanbul. From left to right to left: Gülşah Başkavak, Melike Şahinol, Dursun Baş and Ayşe Berna Uçarol

Rethinking Through Steel

The workshop demonstrated that steel is not simply a technical material. It is a socio-technical entity entangled with imaginaries, which fits squarely within the analytical scope of MediCluster.

This entity exists within circulations that transcend borders, reshape relations of knowledge and power, make epistemic asymmetries legible and link production practices across diverse geographies.

With this session, the analytical arc that MediCluster draws between Samsun, Sialkot, and Tuttlingen gained a deeper layer. Steel emerges not only as a material but also as an interface through which knowledge, labor, power and meaning are redistributed in the global production landscape.

The Anatomy of an Ethics Committee Process: Ethical Design, Approval, and Implementation in the MediCluster Project

The reliability of scientific research is directly related not only to the quality of the results obtained but also to the methods used to achieve these results. Complying with ethical principles is one of the most critical components of this process, especially in research involving human subjects. In the MediCluster project, the ethical process was approached as a comprehensive approach, extending from the design of the research to its field implementation. In this article, we outline the “anatomy” of the ethical dimension of our research, both to share our own experience and to provide a more general framework for ethics committee processes.

Ethical Perspective in Research Design: From Internal Group Discussions to a Common Framework

Following our extensive and demanding literature review, the MediCluster team began preparing for our fieldwork. Before starting the research design, we held a series of internal meetings. These meetings involved much more than discussing the methodological framework of the project: Questions such as how we would protect the experiences of the people interviewed, how we would handle sensitive production information, and how we would meet the cultural and legal expectations in different countries (Germany, Pakistan, Türkiye) formed the cornerstones of our ethical approach. At this stage, we gradually arrived at a common framework while constantly alerting each other to ethical risks.

In these discussions, we particularly agreed on the following point: The ethical process should not be an add-on to the research; it should be a building block that shapes the research itself. This was especially important from our field’s perspective.  Therefore, we treated ethical principles not as an approval step added at the beginning of the design but as a guide shaping all stages of the research.

Ethics Committee Application: Process and Approval from the Max Weber Foundation

Following this common framework, we prepared our application to the ethics committee within the Max Weber Foundation. In the application, we specifically included the following:

    • The purpose and scope of the study
    • Data collection methods (interviews, workplace observations, video/audio recordings of production processes)
    • Data security protocols
    • Our anonymization methods
    • The participant consent process

In order to be able to respond transparently to all questions that the ethics committee might raise, we clearly defined many elements, from field experiences to the technical details of data processing. By establishing patient and continuous communication with the institution, which handled the process with great care during the consent process, we reached an agreement where everything about the process was clearly defined. With the approval, the ethical basis of the research was also confirmed institutionally.

For detailed approval information, see: The DFG-funded research project MediCluster was reviewed and approved by the Ethics Committee of the Max Weber Stiftung (Max Weber Foundation) on July 21, 2025. The committee confirmed that all ethical issues related to working with human data were identified and addressed according to the highest ethical standards (Approval Reference: “2025-03 MediCluster Sahinol OII”).

This process was not merely a formality for us. The questions and guidance provided by the ethics committee strengthened our approach and enabled us to establish a structure that is consistent both legally and scientifically.

Participant Information Process: Flyers Prepared in Three Languages

The most fundamental requirement of the ethics committee was that participants have access to clear and understandable information about the research. Accordingly, the informative flyers we prepared in three languages (German, English, Turkish) became a critical tool for the visibility and trustworthiness of the research.

Our flyers (MediCluster flyers in German, English and Turkish) specifically covered the following topics:

    • The subject and purpose of the research
    • The team conducting the research
    • What participation entails
    • Permission processes in case of audio or video recording
    • Voluntariness and the right to end the interview at any time
    • Anonymization of data and privacy principles
    • Contact information

These documents were crucial for ensuring that the individuals we interviewed in the field understood the research correctly and that informed consent was genuinely provided.

Application of Ethical Principles in the Field: Where Theory Meets Practice

Ensuring that ethical principles were not limited to written documents was one of the most important stages of the research for us. In this context, we strictly are adhering to the following fundamental principles in our fieldwork:

    • Informed Consent

Before starting the interview, participants are given a flyer and all aspects of the research are explained verbally.

From our perspective, consent is not just a signature, but a process of mutual understanding.

    • Complete Confidentiality and Anonymity

Names provided during interviews, identifiable elements of business information, and personal data are anonymized completely anonymous.

Separate coding is used for each participant (e. g., TR10Mas, DE32Exp). At this point, both ethical principles and GDPR and local data protection legislation (such as Türkiye’s Personal Data Protection Law (Kişisel Verileri Koruma Kanunu, KVKK) and Pakistan’s draft Personal Data Protection Bill) are complied with.

    • Security of Records

Audio and video recordings are stored on encrypted devices, kept in encrypted storage areas, and not shared with anyone outside the project team.

    • Right to Leave at Any Time

If participants wish to stop the conversation or speak off-record, the process is immediately halted.

This right is never questioned.

    • Protection of Sensitive Production Information

Since the production of surgical instruments may constitute trade secrets in some businesses, only authorized stages are recorded in video/visual recordings.

Additional flexibility is provided according to the cultural expectations of each country.

Conclusion: The Ethical Process is Not a Procedure, but the Backbone of Research

Our experience with the MediCluster project reminded us that ethical committee approval is not a “starting point” but an ongoing process. Ethics is not just an approval document or a legal requirement; it is a fundamental component that establishes the reliability, transparency, and social responsibility of research.

This article was prepared both to share the ethical design of our project and to provide a guiding framework for teams conducting similar research. Making ethical processes visible makes scientific production itself stronger, more inclusive, and more equitable. For us, ethics is not a step completed at the beginning of the research, but a guide that is continually reconstructed at every stage of the process, reinforced by our experiences, and continuously re-negotiated.

If you would like to receive further information about this project, or if you have any questions regarding data protection, please contact our PI Dr. Melike Şahinol or the Data Protection Officer of the Max Weber Foundation:

Data Protection Officer
Max Weber Foundation – German Humanities Institutes Abroad
Rheinallee 6
D-53173 Bonn, Germany
Phone: +49 (228) 37786-14
E-mail: datenschutz at maxweberstiftung.de

 

 

The Material That Shapes the Scalpel: The Silent Power of Steel in Surgical Instruments

In the MediCluster project, we look at the manufacturing of surgical instruments on three levels: micro (workbench practices, craftsmanship, embodied/tacit knowledge; see: Uçarol, 2025: https://medicluster.hypotheses.org/1017), meso (operational routines and regional cluster logics) and macro (global division of labor, political economy, standards/regulation), comparing manufacturing in Tuttlingen, Sialkot, and Samsun. Our field research in Samsun (TR) so far indicates that steel is the common thread linking Tuttlingen (DE), Sialkot (PK), and Samsun (TR) through their value chains. Stainless steel is not only a material that provides stability, durability, and biocompatibility, but also offers a range of benefits. The material is also a medium or component of supply chains, certification and origin regimes, and price dynamics. Accordingly, we explicitly locate the micro-practices observed in Samsun in interaction with meso- and macro-processes, focusing on the material path (steel grades, traceability, and standard conformity) as the connecting element among the three clusters.

Why Stainless Steel for Surgical Instruments?

Stainless steel is an alloy containing at least 12-13% chromium, resistant to corrosion, formable, and highly durable. In surgical instruments, the martensitic (e.g., AISI 420, 440) and austenitic (e.g., 316L) types of this steel are particularly used. Martensitic steels offer high hardness in cutting instruments, such as scalpels and scissors (WPI, 2025). Austenitic steels are preferred in implant materials due to their high corrosion resistance and biocompatibility (WPI, 2025).

The compliance of these steels with international standards (e.g., ISO 7153-1 or ASTM F899) ensures that the device can be sterilized without rusting, does not damage tissues, and can be used for an extended period. In other words, it is not just about the metal, but the safety and quality commitment it carries (WPI, 2025)

The Element Connecting One Cluster to Another: The Background of Steel Supply

Surgical instrument production is concentrated in only a few regions of the world, including Germany (Tuttlingen), Pakistan (Sialkot), and Türkiye (Samsun). On the one hand, these regions are production centers based on craftsmanship, but on the other hand, they are supported by a well-organized infrastructural steel supply.

Based on field research conducted in Samsun, the critical role of steel for manufacturing surgical instruments was presented by Şahinol (2025) at the 4S Annual Meeting in Seattle. Şahinol (2025) emphasized that not only the craftsmanship of the artisans is crucial, but also the accessibility of steel, which must meet specific quality standards. Despite the significant growth of the industry in Samsun in recent years, expectations for the future remain rather pessimistic. This is because the predominantly imported medical-grade stainless steel increases unit costs depending on the exchange rate (Şahinol 2025).

This coincides with the analyses conducted by Dursun Baş under the IPC umbrella. Baş emphasizes that steel has become a critical element not only for industrial production but also in terms of green transformation, strategic autonomy, and regional competitiveness (Baş 2025). In countries such as Turkey, medical steel production is not only a matter of technology, but also a matter of political orientation and capacity.

From Raw Material to Device: The First Link in the Quality Chain

We observed in the field that the quality of steel at the very beginning of the production chain affects everything, including the surgeon’s experience at the end of the product. For example, most of the instruments produced in Sialkot, Pakistan, are made with steel imported from Germany. Despite this, high scrap rates can occur due to inadequacies in quality control processes.

On the other hand, Germany produces its own steel, according to its own standards, enabling it to maintain high, error-free production rates and sustain its reputation for “high quality” in the global market. This situation also demonstrates that steel supply is not only a logistical issue but also an epistemic one: quality is shaped not only by the purity of the metal but also by the knowledge and control systems surrounding it.

In Conclusion: Steel at the Intersection of Matter, Labor, and Politics

The manufacture of surgical instruments is a socio-technical arrangement. Micromechanical craftsmanship is embedded in global supply chains, regulatory systems, and materials science. If steel is at the heart of production, then standardization, traceability, and biocompatibility are the pulse of that heart. But one must ask, whose? Standards are defined, negotiated, and enforced by specific actors (standardization bodies, regulatory authorities, certification bodies, OEMs, hospitals), and their decisions spread along the value chains that connect Tuttlingen, Sialkot, and Samsun. Understanding these areas of standard setting shows that technical “quality” is also a political and economic agreement.

From a material-semiotic perspective (Law 2023), ‘surgical steel’ is not a neutral substrate but a configured actant. Alloy codes (e.g., ISO/ASTM), traceability routines, tests, and certificates inscribe scripts along the chain: they configure roles (producers, test laboratories, OEMs, purchasers, surgeons, regulators) and prescribe practices. In this “de-scription” (Akrich 1992), ‘quality’ is not merely measured; it is “enacted” (Mol 2002). It emerges from the interplay of material, standards, audits, and craft. Thus, the choice of steel in the scalpel’s body is not only technical but also an expression and effect of a global regime of production and governance.

References

Akrich, M. (1992). The de-scription of technical objects. Shaping technology/building society. Studies in sociotechnical change, 205-224.

Baş, D. (2025). Türkiye çelik sektörünün karbonsuzlaşmaşı: politika ve aktör analizi https://ipc.sabanciuniv.edu/Content/Images/CKeditorImages/20251016-12105955.pdf

Law, J., (2023). Material Semiotics, In P. Atkinson, S. Delamont, A. Cernat, J.W. Sakshaug, & R.A. Williams (Eds.), SAGE Research Methods Foundations. https://doi.org/10.4135/9781529751079747550

Mol, A. (2002). The body multiple: Ontology in medical practice. Duke University Press.

Şahinol, M. (September 7, 2025). Circulating Instruments, Situated Contexts: Reflections from 4S Seattle. Manufacturing Practices of Medical Instruments (MediCluster). Retrieved November 3, 2025 from https://doi.org/10.58079/14lxs

Uçarol, A. B. (September 4, 2025). Tacit Knowledge in the Surgical Instrument Manufacturing Process. Manufacturing Practices of Medical Instruments (MediCluster). Retrieved November 2, 2025 fromhttps://doi.org/10.58079/14lmz

WPI. (2025). Understanding the Types of Stainless Steel for Manufacturing Surgical Instruments. World Precision Instruments.