Digital resources in the Social Sciences and Humanities OpenEdition Our platforms OpenEdition Books OpenEdition Journals Hypotheses Calenda Libraries OpenEdition Freemium Follow us

Paper Walls and Mobile Boundary Infrastructures: MediCluster in Warsaw

Warsaw is a city shaped by reconstruction. Layers of destruction, rebuilding, memory, and mobility remain visibly inscribed into its urban landscape, making the materiality of borders and infrastructures difficult to ignore. It therefore provided a particularly fitting setting for the conference “Border Matters: On Embodiment, Environment and Infrastructure of Border Spaces”, organized by the Max Weber Foundation and hosted by the German Historical Institute Warsaw from 4–6 May 2026. The conference brought together scholars from sociology, anthropology, Science and Technology Studies (STS), history, and border studies to rethink borders beyond fixed territorial lines. Discussions focused instead on bordering processes, infrastructures, mobility, materiality, and the circulation of people, documents, technologies, and environments. The full conference program can be accessed here: https://www.dhi.waw.pl/veranstaltungen/tagungen/detail/stiftungskonferenz-border-matters-embodiment-environment-and-infrastructure-of-border-spaces/  

Promotional poster for the international conference “Border Matters: Embodiment, Environment, and Infrastructure of Border Spaces,” held in Warsaw, Poland, from 4–6 May 2026. The poster features the logos of the German Historical Institute Warsaw and the Max Weber Foundation, with a classical building façade in the background.
Border Matters 2026 International Conference of the Max Weber Foundation Poster

As part of the MediCluster Project, Melike Şahinol, Gülşah Başkavak, and Ayşe Berna Uçarol presented the paper “Beyond Borderlines: Paper Walls as Mobile Boundary Infrastructures in Transnational Surgical-Craftscapes” in the panel “Border-Making Materials,” chaired by Magdalena Saryusz-Wolska.

Three women stand side by side at an academic event, posing in front of two roll-up banners of the German Historical Institute Warsaw. All three wear conference name badges. The woman in the center wears a bright red blazer, while the others are dressed in dark-colored outfits. The photograph was taken indoors and conveys a professional conference setting.
Border Matters 2026 International Conference of the Max Weber Foundation, Warsaw, Poland. From left to right. Ayşe Berna Uçarol, Melike Şahinol, Gülşah Başkavak.

Building on these broader conference discussions, our presentation focused specifically on the role of infrastructures within global medical manufacturing. Rather than treating borders as fixed territorial divisions, we examined how they are continuously enacted through documentary and regulatory systems that organize transnational production.

Rethinking Borders Beyond Geography: From Boundary Objects to Boundary Infrastructures

One of the most stimulating aspects of the conference was the collective move away from understanding borders as merely territorial lines separating nation-states. Across panels and discussions, borders appeared instead as processes: continuously produced through circulation, infrastructures, materiality, documentation, mobility, and regulation.

This broader perspective resonated strongly with our own research trajectory. We examine the global production networks of surgical instruments through extensive fieldwork conducted in Tuttlingen (Germany), Samsun (Türkiye), and Sialkot (Pakistan). Rather than approaching these manufacturing regions as isolated national cases, we conceptualize them as interconnected production geographies linked through technical standards, certification systems, documentation regimes, and unequal recognition structures. We sought to extend this discussion by asking a central question:

What if borders are not only drawn on maps, but also embedded in documents, certificates, technical drawings, export regulations, and quality control procedures?

This question led us to the concept that became central to our presentation: Paper walls.

Within this framework, we questioned the suitability of classical “center–periphery” models (Wallerstein, 1974) and linear production-chain approaches, which are commonly used to explain global production. Instead, we moved from the STS concept of “boundary objects” (Star & Griesemer 1989;  Star 2010) towards an understanding of “boundary infrastructures” (Star & Ruhleder 1996). By shifting the analytical focus from individual objects to the infrastructural arrangements that facilitate coordination, such as documents, standards, and certification processes (Akkerman & Bakker 2011), we approached global production not as a linear structure organized around fixed centers, but as a fragmented yet interconnected “archipelago” operating through networks of circulation and relational ties. In doing so, we demonstrated how documentary and certification practices function as mobile boundary infrastructures that regulate the global circulation of goods (Timmermans & Epstein 2010), while simultaneously producing invisible hierarchies and unequal forms of recognition.

In surgical instrument manufacturing, circulation is not organized solely through products themselves. It is sustained through extensive documentary systems: technical specifications, calibration procedures, audit documents, European Medical Device Regulation (MDR) compliance files, certification protocols, traceability requirements, sterilization standards, and export regulations. These infrastructures coordinate production across countries while simultaneously regulating legitimacy and market access.

To conceptualize this process, we used the notion of “paper walls”, a term repeatedly used by instrument producers/craftsmen during our fieldwork. Producers often referred to the growing burden of regulatory documentation as an invisible wall shaping who can participate in global markets and under what conditions. Unlike conventional borders, paper walls are mobile. They travel through certificates, standards, audits, and regulatory regimes. They do not stop circulation altogether; rather, they filter, slow down, discipline, classify, and hierarchize it. In other words, rather than viewing global production as a linear chain or fixed “center–periphery” model, approaching it as an “archipelago” of interconnected yet unequal relations allows us to view production processes differently. Adopting the “oceanic perspective” (Şahinol 2025), materials, knowledge, legitimacy, and innovation are viewed as constantly circulating across various production nodes. This approach reveals that boundaries are not fixed structures existing outside these relations but are instead continuously produced and reproduced within these circulation processes.

These infrastructural dynamics become particularly visible when examining the organization of surgical instrument manufacturing itself. Our fieldwork suggests that production cannot adequately be understood through linear supply-chain models alone. Instead, the sector operates through fragmented yet interconnected production environments shaped by mobility, craftsmanship, standards, and unequal forms of recognition.

Surgical Manufacturing as a Transnational Craftscape

While global surgical instrument manufacturing is often described through industrial supply-chain models, our fieldwork highlights the continuing importance of craftsmanship within these production environments. Surgical manufacturing depends not only on technical standards and regulatory infrastructures, but also on embodied knowledge, manual precision, tacit learning processes, and intergenerational expertise.

Across production sites in Tuttlingen, Samsun, and Sialkot, craftsmanship remains central even within highly standardized manufacturing contexts. Precision is not achieved through documents alone. It also relies on sensory experience, skilled handwork, and locally embedded forms of practical knowledge that are difficult to standardize completely.

This is why we use the concept of surgical craftscapes. The term emphasizes that surgical manufacturing is simultaneously industrial, infrastructural, and craft-based. At the same time, these craftscapes are increasingly shaped by documentary and regulatory regimes that determine visibility, legitimacy, and access to global markets.

Paper Walls Across Scales

To better understand how paper walls operate within global surgical manufacturing, we approached them across micro, meso, and macro levels.

At the micro level of everyday production and standardization (Bowker & Star 1999), paper walls shape production practices inside workshops and factories. Technical drawings, calibration procedures, measurement protocols, quality-control documents, and compliance routines do not simply record production; they actively organize it. These documents determine what counts as precision, which deviations become acceptable, and how “quality” itself is materially enacted. In this sense, standardization becomes embedded in daily labor practices.

The meso level refers to recognition and trust, and paper walls function through recognition infrastructures. Labels such as “Made in Germany” do not merely indicate geographic origin. They circulate as condensed symbols of trust, quality, reliability, and legitimacy within global medical markets. Thus, borders emerge not only through customs regulations or territorial restrictions, but also through uneven structures of credibility.

At the macro level, regulatory systems increasingly shape access to international markets. In particular, the European MDR regime has become a powerful infrastructural actor within the global surgical instruments sector. MDR does not simply regulate products entering Europe. Its effects extend across the entire production geography. Importantly, the regulatory burden does not affect only manufacturers outside Europe. Small and medium-sized firms within Europe also struggle with increasing documentation requirements, certification costs, and administrative complexity.

An Important Discussion: Pediatric Devices

One of the most important moments of the conference emerged during the discussion following our presentation, when participants raised the issue of pediatric devices and the growing difficulty of sustaining the production of highly specialized instruments manufactured in small quantities. We found this discussion particularly important because it revealed the broader implications of our argument in a very concrete way.

Pediatric surgical instruments represent a revealing example of how regulatory infrastructures reshape production priorities within global medical manufacturing. These devices are often highly specialized and produced in comparatively low volumes. Under increasingly complex regulatory frameworks such as the European MDR, however, the costs associated with documentation, testing, certification, clinical evaluation, traceability, and compliance can become disproportionately high relative to the size of production runs.

As a result, manufacturers may discontinue certain products not because of technological incapacity or lack of expertise, but because maintaining regulatory compliance becomes economically unsustainable. Recent industry reports and surveys in Germany already point to the withdrawal of specialized medical products from the market, particularly affecting smaller manufacturers and highly specialized devices. Concerns have also been raised regarding pediatric and so-called “orphan” medical devices, whose limited production volumes make them especially vulnerable under current MDR conditions.

Here, paper walls become directly visible. The “wall” is not a physical prohibition preventing production. Rather, it emerges through layers of documentation, audit requirements, risk assessments, certification costs, and administrative obligations that increasingly determine which products remain viable within global markets — and which gradually disappear from circulation.

Bordering Through Infrastructure

The discussions in Warsaw reinforced an important insight for our ongoing MediCluster research: within global medical manufacturing, borders increasingly emerge through documentary, regulatory, and infrastructural practices that shape circulation, legitimacy, and market access.

In the next stages of the project, particularly through forthcoming fieldwork in Sialkot, we aim to further investigate how these boundary infrastructures are experienced, negotiated, and contested across different production clusters within the global surgical instruments industry.

Warsaw provided an especially fitting setting for these discussions. As a city marked by reconstruction, mobility, and layered histories of bordering, it offered a powerful reminder that borders are not simply lines on maps. More often, they operate quietly through documents, certifications, standards, infrastructures, and everyday administrative practices.

And sometimes, the most powerful walls are made of paper.

References

Akkerman, S. F., & Bakker, A. (2011). Boundary crossing and boundary objects. Review of Educational Research, 81(2), 132–169.

Bowker, G. C., & Star, S. L. (1999). Sorting things out: Classification and its consequences. MIT Press.

Star, S. L., & Griesemer, J. R. (1989). Institutional ecology, “translations” and boundary objects: Amateurs and professionals in Berkeley’s Museum of Vertebrate Zoology, 1907–39. Social Studies of Science, 19(3), 387–420.

Star, S. L., & Ruhleder, K. (1996). Steps toward an ecology of infrastructure: Design and access for large information spaces. Information Systems Research, 7(1), 111–134.

Star, S. L. (2010). This is not a boundary object: Reflections on the origin of a concept. Science, Technology, & Human Values, 35(5), 601–617.

Timmermans, S., & Epstein, S. (2010). A world of standards but not a standard world: Toward a sociology of standards and standardization. Annual Review of Sociology, 36, 69–89.

Şahinol, M. (2025, August 29). Paper Walls and Endless Circulations: Epistemic Asymmetry in Surgical Instrument Manufacturing.  https://doi.org/10.58079/14jtr

Wallerstein, I. (1974). The Modern World-System: Capitalist Agriculture and the Origins of the European World-Economy in the Sixteenth Century. Academic Press.

 

Walking the Cluster: Urban Memory, Craft, and Medical Manufacturing in Tuttlingen

What factors contribute to a city’s significance beyond its physical size? In Tuttlingen’s case, this question cannot be answered solely by quantitative measures such as population statistics or export data. The city’s importance is also shaped by the ways it narrates its own history, including its bridges, workshops, monuments, family histories, and the transmission of skills across generations.

Before beginning our interviews and site visits in Tuttlingen, the second major field site of the MediCluster project after Samsun, we spent two days exploring the city with Klaus Hug, a volunteer city guide affiliated with the municipality. What initially appeared to be orientation work soon developed into a more substantive research activity. The guided tour became an integral part of our research collection, offering not only historical context but also insights into how Tuttlingen publicly commemorates and spatially organizes its industrial heritage.

Methodologically, this was significant. We do not view the city tour as a neutral introduction to “actual” fieldwork, but as a research encounter in its own right. It demonstrated how urban-industrial identity is narrated on site: through selected stops, recurring anecdotes, symbolic objects, and the guide’s own sequencing of the city’s past and present. In this way, the tour provided a situated form of urban knowledge — one that linked memory, industry, space, and local self-understanding (Halbwachs 1992; de Certeau 1984).

Walking Tuttlingen with Klaus Hug: A Witness to Urban-Industrial Memory

Klaus Hug is not simply a guide who recounts historical facts. He is also a carrier of local memory, someone who narrates the city through accumulated familiarity, repetition, and lived observation. During our two days with him, we gained insight not only into Tuttlingen’s history but also into a local perspective on the factors shaping the city’s current identity. This distinction is significant: Hug’s narratives do not simply recount the cluster’s development; they actively contribute to the ongoing construction of its social meaning.

This is precisely why his narration holds sociological significance. Industrial clusters are maintained not solely through production, but also through collective memory, symbolic representation, and spatial narratives that render their existence coherent, enduring, and rooted in the local context.

Video 1: Klaus Hug introduces Tuttlingen through the Danube bridge, trade routes, water, tanning, and the historical linkage between leatherwork, knife-making, and later surgical specialization.

Our walk started at the Danube bridge, a deliberate and significant starting point. Hug introduces Tuttlingen’s history through the lens of commerce, crossing, and trade. While standing on the bridge, he explains that merchants traveling between Stuttgart, Switzerland, and Lake Constance historically passed through this location and paid tolls, which rendered the bridge a crucial source of income for the city.

This introduction is analytically significant. The narrative of Tuttlingen’s industry is initially presented as one of infrastructure and movement. Rather than focusing on a factory or a prominent entrepreneur, Hug begins with a bridge. In doing so, he frames economic development in terms of circulation, spatial positioning, and material connectivity (de Certeau 1984; Lefebvre 1991/1992).

Hug then turns to the river itself: water representing life, settlement, subsistence, and productive potential. In his narration, water enabled not only habitation but also the practical work of early crafts. Where people settled, tanning developed; where tanning developed, tools became necessary; and where tools were needed, expertise in cutting, scraping, sharpening, and handling metal began to strengthen.

Hug explains that this area was once a significant tannery district, with the odor of leather processing permeating the entire town. He further emphasizes a critical connection: the demands of leatherworking necessitated high-quality knives, which gradually cultivated local expertise in metal tools and their production.

From a sociological perspective, this account extends beyond a simple origin story. It constitutes a spatial narrative that links water, trade, craft practices, and subsequent industrial specialization into a coherent genealogy of the regional cluster. Rather than depicting Tuttlingen’s medical industry as an isolated industrial phenomenon, the tour situates it within a longstanding material context of circulation, tanning, knife-making, and adaptive practices.

From Knife Town to Surgical Instrument Production

In the tour narrative, Tuttlingen first becomes a city of knives, then a city of surgical instruments. This is a crucial transition in the local story of industrial specialization. Hunting knives, pocketknives, and household knives were already part of the town’s craft world, but surgical instruments promised a different economic horizon. As Hug remarks, the price difference between an ordinary knife and a surgical knife was large enough to reorient local production.

Rather than describing this shift as a natural progression from leather to knives and from knives to surgery, it is more precise to understand it as a process of selective reorientation. Existing skills, tool knowledge, and artisanal precision were not simply carried over; they were redirected toward a more profitable, medically specialized area (Howells 2002).

This matters because it avoids a teleological reading. Tuttlingen did not inevitably become what it is today. Instead, local actors identified a niche, adapted existing capabilities to a new field, and integrated that shift into a changing urban and regional economy (Amin and Thrift 1994).

The Fire of 1803 and the Reorganization of Urban Space

The fire of 1803 remains a significant reference point in local stories about Tuttlingen. Much of the medieval town was destroyed, and the rebuilding process changed not only the physical environment but also how the town later viewed its own development. In local memory, the fire is seen less as a single disaster and more as a moment when destruction, adaptation, and urban change became interconnected. The destruction of medieval structures and the rebuilding efforts, including the unique roof shape known locally as the Tuttlinger Hut, still form part of the city’s remembered history.

Rather than framing the fire as the direct cause of later industrial success, it is more useful to understand its significance in retrospective terms. Sociologically, the importance of the fire lies in how it became woven into a broader story of resilience and transformation. The disaster did not automatically lead to a medical cluster, but within the city’s collective memory it became part of a narrative in which rebuilding, practical adaptation, and artisanal knowledge later came to be seen as foundations for a new urban-industrial path. In this sense, the fire marks both a reorganization of urban space and a shift in how the city recounts its own past.

Gottfried Jetter: Mobility, Return, and Local Re-Embedding

A particularly notable stop on the tour was the Jetter House at Obere Vorstadt 20, which Hug specifically highlights as a place linked to Tuttlingen’s later growth as a hub for medical technology. The story he shares there is compelling not because it presents a heroic founder myth, but because it connects mobility, learning, kinship, and local return. Gottfried Jetter, born in this house in 1838, trained as a knife maker, moved to Paris, encountered instrument making there, met Rosine Scherer, and eventually returned to start a workshop for surgical instruments. In Hug’s account, Jetter’s biography simplifies a larger network dynamic: knowledge spreads outward, is transformed elsewhere, and then is re-embedded locally through partnerships and family ties.

This is where the post can become more explicitly sociological without losing readability. Jetter’s trajectory should not be framed solely as an individual success story. It is better understood as a relational story of cluster formation. What matters is not only that he returned, but that his return itself became productive through existing traditions of knife making, regional familiarity, and family-based organization. The later development of Jetter und Scherer, and eventually Aesculap, can then be seen not as an isolated breakthrough, but as an early formation of a local production ecology that combined artisanal skill, entrepreneurial decision-making, and social ties.

Video 2. Jetter House, Family Partnership, and Early Surgical Instrument Production  – Video caption. At the Jetter House, Klaus Hug recounts the story of Gottfried Jetter and links entrepreneurial origins to local return, family partnership, and the formation of an early surgical instrument workshop.

Clustering in Tuttlingen: Competition, Interdependence, and the Social Infrastructure of Production

One of the most striking questions raised by the tour concerns the coexistence within such a small geographical area. Hug’s answer is telling:

“Here, competition exists not to destroy one another, but to make one another better.”

Indeed, firms in the region often occupy the dual position of being both customers and suppliers to one another within the same supply chain. As specialization has deepened, interdependence has also intensified, giving rise to an ecosystem based on mutual benefit, yet one that remains fragile. What appears here is not merely a concentration of firms, but a social infrastructure of production built on specialization, proximity, and long-standing practical ties.

This becomes even clearer in Hug’s remarks on small workshops and subcontracting arrangements. He describes a world in which a father could support an entire household through highly specialized supply work for only one or two surgical firms. In some workshops, components for competing firms could lie side by side, carefully separated, while producers navigated exclusivity, dependence, and everyday compromise. What emerges here is not simply an industrial cluster, but a socially embedded production ecology sustained by household livelihoods, subcontracting relations, embodied expertise, and local trust (Amin and Thrift 1994).

Video 3. A Bronze Monument: The Symbol of Craftsmanship

Video caption: In front of the master–apprentice sculpture, Klaus Hug reflects on precision, workshop discipline, and the transmission of manual skill in Tuttlingen’s surgical instrument tradition.

In the streets of Tuttlingen stands a sculpture by Roland Martin. Hug continued his account as he showed it to us. The work depicts a master craftsman holding a pair of forceps, and his apprentice standing at a vise. The master is demonstrating to the apprentice how the forceps should be closed — how the two arms must meet with exact precision. Both figures are wearing work aprons.

Hug and we stood before the sculpture for some time. It has had to be repaired several times because people pulled at it so forcefully that it was damaged. Laughing, he remarked, “Someone, probably drunk at night, tried to break off the forceps.” Yet the symbolic weight of the sculpture is beyond dispute: it is a visual expression of knowledge transmitted from master to apprentice — the very process that made this city’s growth possible across generations.

More than just a decorative monument, the sculpture captures a local understanding of how industrial quality is reproduced. It embodies precision, skill, discipline, and intergenerational learning in a public urban object. In this way, it not only commemorates craftsmanship but also makes visible the social process through which the cluster reproduces itself.

Tuttlingen Today: Extending the Cluster, Reworking Its Foundations

Tuttlingen’s current industrial profile is defined by a cluster that extends well beyond traditional scalpels and forceps production. The integration of robotic surgical systems, endoscopic devices, and digital health technologies has diversified its industrial landscape. However, this growth is accompanied by significant challenges, including shortages of skilled labor, heightened global competition, dependencies on steel supply, sustainability requirements, and increasingly complex certification processes, all of which influence the cluster’s present operating environment.

This development does not represent a straightforward shift from tradition to modernity, but rather a continual reconfiguration of the cluster’s foundational principles. Observations indicate that continuity and change coexist within Tuttlingen’s industrial landscape. Although production shifts into new technological areas, local ideas of quality remain rooted in precision, manual skill, and meticulous craftsmanship. Therefore, the cluster’s future relies not only on innovation but also on adapting and reinterpreting established knowledge and practices in response to changing industrial conditions.

What Remained After Two Days with Klaus Hug

By the time we said farewell to Klaus Hug, the afternoon was well advanced. Despite hours spent walking through the city in the bitter cold, he continued to share stories as we gathered over hot coffee and Swabian pastries.

As we watched him depart, one impression remained with us: a city’s memory is not confined to archives and books. It also endures in individuals who connect places, events, and practices through narration. At each stop, Hug linked the visible city to a broader history of production, adaptation, and urban transformation. The Danube played a significant role, yet many cities are situated along rivers. Metalworking traditions were important, but not all of them have led to global industrial specialization. The fire of 1803 was a significant rupture, but destruction alone does not account for why one town reorganizes itself in ways that later become economically consequential.

The tour revealed not a single cause, but a historically layered configuration: Gottfried Jetter’s outward mobility and return, the practical ingenuity of the Scherer family, the increasing influence of Aesculap on the urban fabric, and the workshop-based production methods that enabled competing orders to coexist. Collectively, these elements indicate a local culture of making that evolved through interdependence, adaptation, and the ongoing refinement of inherited skills.

This, perhaps, is the most evident lesson from Tuttlingen’s history. Industrial success is not determined solely by geography or raw materials. It also relies on social relations, shared knowledge, public memory, and urban arrangements that are continually reproduced. During our two-day visit, we observed traces of this history in bridges, houses, workshops, monuments, and stories. Tuttlingen, however, has been generating such traces for much longer.

References

Amin, A., & Thrift, N. (1994). Living in the Global. In A. Amin & N. Thrift (Eds.), Globalization, institutions, and regional development in Europe (pp. 1-22). Oxford University Press.

de Certeau, M. (1984). Walking in the City. In The Practice of Everyday Life (pp. 91–110). University of California Press.

Halbwachs, M. (1992). On collective memory. Lewis A. Coser (Ed.). University of Chicago Press.

Howells, J. R. L. (2002). Tacit Knowledge, Innovation, and Economic Geography. Urban Studies, 39(5–6), 871–884.

Lefebvre, H. (1991). The Production of Space. Blackwell.

MEDICA as a Global Socio-Technical Marketplace: Sociological Fieldnotes

This blog post presents ethnographic fieldnotes from MEDICA 2025, where exhibitors from our three MediCluster regions – Tuttlingen, Sialkot, and Samsun – converged in a shared global marketplace. It shows how the fair operates as a socio-technical field in which craft knowledge, production cultures, and innovation narratives meet and circulate. These observations form an integral part of our comparative ethnography on surgical-instrument manufacturing. 

One of the most significant global gatherings in the medical technology and device sector, MEDICA, was held this year at Messe Düsseldorf, attracting more than 5,300 participants from over 70 countries. The trade fair showcased a wide range of products, from surgical instruments to cutting-edge medical technologies, across its many booths. While it is primarily a commercial trade fair, it also serves as a rich socio-technical system where innovation, supply chains, circulation, and regulatory processes interact as active forces shaping the field. Among the fair’s more unusual visitors this year were Melike and me, attending as sociologists! 

Photo 1: The entry point to the MEDICA exhibition grounds in Düsseldorf (from left to right: Melike Şahinol Gülşah Başkavak)
Photo 1: The entry point to the MEDICA exhibition grounds in Düsseldorf (from left to right: Melike Şahinol Gülşah Başkavak)

First Encounters: Tuttlingen, Sialkot and the Global Cluster Landscape 

The primary purpose of this preliminary fieldwork in Düsseldorf was to meet companies based in Tuttlingen, our second research site, and to establish initial connections to guide our upcoming fieldwork in Germany. We were able to speak directly with numerous company representatives and owners from the Tuttlingen cluster, conducting several brief yet insightful interviews. Unexpectedly, we also established strong connections with surgical instrument manufacturers from Sialkot, our third field site, who were exhibiting at the fair as well. These encounters opened up productive conversations about manufacturing practices and regional production cultures. While our primary focus was on German firms and, to a lesser extent, Pakistani ones, the nature of our ethnographic observations led us to walk through and engage with nearly all the exhibitors in medical/surgical instrument manufacturing across three to four large halls, allowing for short yet significant exchanges. From a sociological perspective, these encounters clearly show that the exchange of knowledge in the global production of medical instruments cannot be understood solely through technological or commercial networks. Instead, it is also influenced by social and cultural relationships, face-to-face interactions, and the everyday practices that define the industry. As a result, our observations in Düsseldorf provided a solid foundation for the ethnographic work we will soon undertake in Tuttlingen. 

Mobilities and Micro-Spaces of Observation 

While staying in the nearby city of Duisburg and commuting daily to Düsseldorf, I quickly noticed that the 50-minute train ride had morphed into an extension of the fair itself. The sight of passengers with Düsseldorf Messe name badges set the tone, turning the train into a lively microcosm of MEDICA. I saw engineers or company representatives toting product prototypes in their backpacks, sales staff outlining their day’s plans, small teams discussing supply-chain challenges, and exhibitors hurrying to finalize their booth setups. This vibrant atmosphere created a multilingual buzz, enhancing our observations as we traveled. It soon became clear that the fair did not simply begin at the exhibition entrance; instead, it spilled over into the everyday rhythms of the region, crafting a continuous field of experience that stretched all the way from Duisburg. Even the small café next to the station became a condensed micro-sociological hub of MEDICA, where its dynamics were laid bare. 

Photo 2- During the train journey from Duisburg to Düsseldorf, there were encounters with various actors at the fair (from left to right: Gülşah Başkavak, Melike Şahinol)

Craft, Steel and the Invisible Labour Behind Surgical Instruments 

High-precision surgical instruments, robotic systems, AI-assisted clinical applications, sterilization technologies… Beyond the impressive technological landscape that greets you at the fair lies a tapestry of human stories woven into these innovations. Behind every medical instrument product are visible/invisible labor processes, craft-based skills, pressures of strict standardization, comprehensive certification procedures, and strategies that meet global competition head-on. In my field notes, these often-unseen structures carry equal analytical weight as the devices’ technical specifications. Indeed, these processes were the essence of our observations during our rewarding fieldwork in Samsun earlier this summer.

In conversations with representatives from major surgical instrument manufacturing hubs such as Tuttlingen, Sialkot, and Samsun, a recurring theme stood out. One aspect I want to emphasize from my observations is the practice of working with steel. The shaping of steel material may seem like a simple production process. However, forming, hardening, and refining steel involves culturally embedded craft-based knowledge passed down through generations. 

Photo 3-Surgical scissors

During this fieldwork, I recalled a series of surgical scenes observed throughout my doctoral research. The surgeon, a craftsman and the end user of a surgical instrument, approaches steel not merely as a tool in their occupation but as an integral component of their surgical practice. 

Photo 4- A snapshot from ethnographic observations conducted in operating theatres during my doctoral research ©Gülşah Başkavak

The way surgeons understand and use their instruments demonstrates a complex interdependence among tools, craftsmanship, and medical expertise, making this interdependence visible in the operating theatre’s practiced routines. The production of a single pair of surgical scissors encompasses a range of complex elements, including sensory motor skills, tacit knowledge, master-apprentice relationships, and the historical context of family-owned enterprises within medical clusters. Additionally, these factors are interlinked with global supply chains and the continuously evolving quality standards.  

During my visit to the Düsseldorf Messe, I was particularly struck not only by the dynamic interplay of production cultures as they interacted and transformed through these encounters. The importance of steel was a prominent theme throughout the fair. This was evident in product demonstrations, technical specifications, sustainability discussions, and casual conversations with manufacturers at various stands. As a result, we decided to proactively organize a series of workshops focused on steel once we returned.

Innovation, Green Technologies and Negotiating the Future of the Industry 

As I moved from one booth to another, striking words began to emerge. The concepts I encountered most frequently at the fair, often displayed on the walls of nearly every booth, were “innovation” and “future”. However, the meaning and scope of innovation vary widely across regions. Based on informal conversations and observed marketing narratives, innovation in Germany appeared to be often associated with precision, durability, and strict adherence to the highest standards. In contrast, within the scope of these observations, manufacturers from South Asia were often presented as emphasizing competitive pricing, rapid solution development, and quicker access to global markets. This difference highlights that innovation is not just about technical performance; it is a relational concept influenced by economic context, varying craft practices, and the geographies of production. 

One other aspect that genuinely caught my attention during the fair was the growing visibility of sustainability and green technology across the healthcare and medical technology sectors. Walking through the stands, engaging in brief, on-the-spot conversations with exhibitors, and browsing through brochures, I repeatedly encountered sustainability-oriented language and imagery. These encounters gave me the sense that green technology and environmental responsibility are increasingly shaping expectations and placing tangible pressure on actors across the sector. 

The tightening of EU regulations, rising certification requirements, expanding manufacturer responsibility policies, obligations for raw material traceability, and new waste management standards present both opportunities and challenges – especially for small and medium-sized producers.  

These dynamics have transformed the fair from a simple platform for showcasing products into a space for negotiating the industry’s future. Analysing these negotiations from a sociological perspective is essential for highlighting the social and cultural dimensions of global value chains. 

Reflections and Outlook: Preparing for Fieldwork in Tuttlingen 

During our brief visit to the Düsseldorf MEDICA Messe, we encountered a rich array of data invaluable to researchers studying global production geographies and craft-based knowledge systems. The initial connections we established with firms in the Tuttlingen cluster and with manufacturers in Sialkot laid a crucial strategic foundation for our upcoming fieldwork. This preliminary research not only helped us build valuable relationships but also provided a clearer understanding of the material culture, operational practices, and competitive dynamics within the global medical instrument sector.   

Even on the train back to Duisburg at the end of each day, my thoughts about the fair continued… One of the surprises of Germany’s cold November days is the opportunity to experience its wonderful Christmas markets (Weihnachtsmarkt in German). As I walked through the stalls in subzero temperatures, illuminated by the warm glow of the market lights and sipping mulled wine, I found myself reflecting on the craftsmanship and accumulated knowledge behind the hundreds of surgical instruments displayed at the fair. I was also thinking about the upcoming fieldwork in Tuttlingen. In that moment, it became clear to me how transformative it is to observe the networks involved in the manufacturing of surgical instruments in person, and I felt genuinely excited about the data and insights that the Tuttlingen fieldwork will provide! 

Photo 5- German Christmas market (Weihnachtsmarkt)

References
Başkavak, G. (2016). Understanding Surgical Craft in the Changing Context of Technology, Transformation of Healthcare and Marketization: A Case Study on Surgeons in Istanbul [Ph.D., Sociology, Middle East Technical University-METU]. https://etd.lib.metu.edu.tr/upload/12620889/index.pdf 

Başkavak, Gülşah (August 14, 2025). Fieldnotes from Samsun (Türkiye): Listening to the Masters – MediCluster Project. Manufacturing Practices of Medical Instruments (MediCluster). Retrieved December 12, 2025 from https://doi.org/10.58079/14hd1  

Kocager, Uğur (November 27, 2025). A Gathering on the Multiple Ontologies of Steel: A Workshop on Circulation, Knowledge, and Socio-Technical Imaginaries. Manufacturing Practices of Medical Instruments (MediCluster). Retrieved December 10, 2025 from https://doi.org/10.58079/158ds  

 

Fieldnotes from Samsun (Türkiye): Listening to the Masters – MediCluster Project

We (Gülşah Başkavak and Melike Şahinol) are currently on the second day of our fieldwork for the MediCluster Project. Located approximately 700 kilometers from Istanbul, Samsun lies in the heart of the Black Sea region. Historically, this city has been a crossroads for trade, migration, and cultural exchange. Today, often referred to as “The Gateway of the Black Sea to the World”, Samsun serves as a key regional economic hub. Its port, industrial zones, and strong tradition of craftsmanship anchor its position in both national and international markets.

At 10:30 a.m., as arranged, we arrive at the factory. Upon entering, we are greeted by the deep, resonant hum of the machines. The air is heavy, hot, and humid. The wide workshop doors are fully open, allowing an occasional breeze from the Black Sea to carry the sounds of the machinery out into the open air.

Today, we started our one-on-one interviews with the masters. We listened as they shared their occupational journeys, providing valuable insights into their working practices, craft backgrounds, and production techniques. We learned about the intricate process behind making a surgical scissor: A task much more complex than it may seem at first glance. Each craft narrative serves as a testament to the meticulous manual labor that is central to the manufacturing of surgical instruments.

A single component of a surgical scissor during production, Samsun.                       Photo by Gülşah Başkavak, 14.08.2025.

In the workshops, the masters often combine techniques they learned decades ago with new materials and machinery. Our initial observations suggest that Samsun’s significance lies not only in its production capacity but also in the historical traces of knowledge and skills transferred from one craft to another over generations. We will keep listening to the masters. In the coming days, we plan to visit more factories, conduct detailed observations on-site, and carry out in-depth interviews.

By the end of the day, we arrived at Atakum Beach, where long stretches of golden sand extended toward the horizon. The sights and sounds of the day -the masters’ narratives, their voices, and the rhythm of their work- remained vivid in our minds. Under a slowly darkening sky, the Black Sea gently lapped its waves against the shore. On the horizon, the sun set, painting the water in shades of orange, pink, and violet. This second day of fieldwork not only satisfied our academic curiosity but also deepened our research interest in the rich culture of surgical craftsmanship in this city.

Atakum, Samsun. Photo by Gülşah Başkavak, 14.08.2025