Digital resources in the Social Sciences and Humanities OpenEdition Our platforms OpenEdition Books OpenEdition Journals Hypotheses Calenda Libraries OpenEdition Freemium Follow us

Crafting Technotopias: Insights from the STS Türkiye 2025 Conference

This blog post offers a reflection on our contribution to the STS Türkiye 2025 Conference, highlighting how the MediCluster project engaged with discussions on craft, design, and global circulations within surgical instrument manufacturing.

Context: STS Türkiye 2025 Conference

The STS Türkiye 2025 Conference, “Technotopias – Imaginaries of the Past, Present, and Future,” took place on November 6–7, 2025, at HECAS – Hekimbaşı Center for Advanced Studies in Istanbul. Guided by the theme Technotopias – Imaginaries of the Past, Present, and Future, STS Türkiye 2025 gathered researchers from across disciplines to reflect on how science and technology shape — and are shaped by — socialtechnical imaginaries and everyday worlds.

The image is a poster for the STS Turkey 2025: Technotopias, Past, Present, and Future Imaginations conference, jointly organized by STS Turkey and HECAS. The image includes the conference location and date.
STS Türkiye 2025 Conference Poster

In the opening speech, Melike Şahinol invited us to rethink technotopias as lived, situated formations rooted in material practices and embodied expertise. This perspective framed many of the conversations that followed.

Melike Şahinol is presenting the STS Türkiye 2025 conference opening speech at HECAS

As part of the conference program, the panel “Craft, Design, and the Body”, chaired by Melike Şahinol, featured a talk by the MediCluster researchers, sharing insights from our ongoing research on global surgical instrument manufacturing.

The Panel Context

Our panel “Craft, Design, and the Body” brought together complementary perspectives on how craft, design, and technology shape sociotechnical futures. We opened the session with our joint presentation, which introduced findings from the Samsun fieldwork and examined surgical instrument production as part of globally circulating sociotechnical craftscapes.

This was followed by Dijan Özkurt’s contribution, exploring the Istanbul Design Biennial as a site where design functions as a relational practice and an infrastructure for producing public imaginaries. The final presentation by Burak Öztürk reflected on symbiotic art and the forms of human–machine co-agency that emerge in creative processes, prompting a rethinking of embodiment and aesthetic experience.

Together, the panel’s contributions demonstrated that craft, design, and innovation are deeply intertwined practices. Each talk highlighted how future imaginaries are shaped through material engagements, embodied expertise, and relational forms of making – reinforcing the conference theme of technotopias as lived and continuously negotiated formations.

Our Contribution: Local Craft Practices in Samsun

Building on this broader conversation, our presentation introduced the MediCluster Project and focused specifically on the Samsun field site – one of the three interconnected production clusters we examine alongside Tuttlingen and Sialkot. Drawing on completed fieldwork, including in-depth interviews and video ethnography conducted across enterprises of different scales, we traced how surgical instrument production in Samsun forms part of wider sociotechnical craftscapes shaped by embodied knowledge, material practices, and global circulations.

Gülşah Başkavak presenting “Reshaping the Future through the Heritage of Craftsmanship: The Sociotechnical Landscapes of Local Craft Practices in Samsun,” STS Türkiye 2025, HECAS, Istanbul

A key point of discussion was how instruments, ideas, and expertise move across regions, shaping technological geographies – the technotopias – of the future. By situating local craft practices within these global flows, we highlighted how Samsun’s production culture contributes to, and is transformed by, the circulations of skills, materials, and standards.

Reflections from the Discussion: “Sociotechnical Craftscapes” and the “Oceanic Perspective”

The discussion began by emphasizing the global significance of surgical instruments. Within this framework, the vital impact of surgical tools on living beings, the coexistence of automation and manual skill in production processes, and the various forms of specialization within global supply chains were addressed.

In the later stages of the session, the conceptual frameworks of “sociotechnical craftscapes” and the “oceanic perspective” (Şahinol, 2025) provided the theoretical grounding for the discussion. Through these concepts, the group highlighted that sociotechnical craftscapes are not neutral spaces but are shaped by historically rooted global inequalities. They show how imaginaries of medical technologies emerge within uneven conditions of recognition, mobility, and access to resources — and how local practices both navigate and challenge these asymmetries.

Şahinol emphasized that the oceanic perspective serves to unsettle rigid binaries such as center–periphery and North–South without ignoring their material effects. Rather than assuming free circulation, it draws attention to the frictions, blockages, and power relations that structure how knowledge, materials, and standards move across regions. As Şahinol noted, this perspective does not replace North–South or coloniality debates but deepens them by revealing how colonial power is enacted, redistributed, and contested through circulation itself — affecting actors across regions, from small manufacturers in so-called centers who struggle under tightening EU regulatory regimes to producers in places like Türkiye who experience these same regimes as paper walls that limit access and recognition. This approach makes it possible to see how global inequalities are reproduced through circulation — and how places like Samsun negotiate space within these uneven landscapes.

Shaping the Future Through the Traces of the Past: Samsun’s Craft Heritage

Samsun’s longstanding craft heritage illustrates how the future of medical instrument production emerges through the continuous interplay of past knowledge, present practices, and future aspirations. Historical craft traditions remain embedded in everyday production routines and influence contemporary political, economic, and technological decisions. Technotopias – the spaces of future technologies – take shape precisely in these flows, gestures, and fine-tuned adjustments of craft.

From the Field: Technotopias of Craft

  • Tacit Knowledge – At the heart of craftsmanship lies a form of knowledge that cannot be fully expressed in words or writing — tacit knowledge. A master cannot easily explain how they do their work but can demonstrate it in practice. This is a bodily form of knowing, learned through the senses — touch, sight, hearing, even smell. Alongside written ISO standards, there also exist “felt standards” — the sensory protocols of the craftsman.
  • Material Regimes – Material regimes constitute the invisible strategic framework of production. The quality of steel, the order of processing, and the surface finish determine not only the technical value of a product but also its status and the markets it can access. In Samsun, masters do more than shape steel; they shape its place within the global market.
  • Circulation and Recognition – Brand, origin, and expertise do not always align — there is a constant tension between them. Certification processes build “paper walls” that restrict the circulation of knowledge and labor. Yet, user-centered design and the sensory sensibility of craftsmanship serve as critical junctions that guide the direction of future technotopias.

From the Field: The Co-Production Matrix — Reading the Future of Craftsmanship

Analyzing the Samsun fieldwork through the lens of a co-production matrix reveals how norms, local practices, and material possibilities continuously shape one another. The “fine-tuning” gestures and sequences of operations observed in workshops already carry traces of the future within the present.

The co-production matrix is not merely a technical matter; it is also intertwined with questions of recognition and global positioning. Smart incentive policies that consider Samsun’s historical craft heritage and its layered traditions could negotiate between local knowledge and global quality regimes — paving the way for a more just and sustainable future of production.

The image features a diagram showing three boxes interacting in two directions. The first box contains Global Norms, the second box contains Local Practices, and the third box contains Material Possibilities.
Source: “Co-Production Matrix and Trajectories,“ in Şahinol, M., Başkavak, G., and Uçarol, A. B. (2025).

Future Orientation

The discussion reaffirmed that craftsmanship is not a remnant of the past, but a vital, living knowledge practice shaping the production worlds of tomorrow. With upcoming fieldwork in Tuttlingen and Sialkot, we aim to deepen our comparative understanding of how different clusters specialize within global surgical instrument supply chains. The thoughtful questions from the audience provided valuable impulses for the next phases of our research.

STS Türkiye 2025 conference snapshot, HECAS, Istanbul. From left to right: Ayşe Berna Uçarol, Gülşah Başkavak, Melike Şahinol
STS Türkiye 2025 conference snapshot, HECAS, Istanbul. From left to right: Ayşe Berna Uçarol, Gülşah Başkavak, Melike Şahinol

Ayşe Berna Uçarol
Ayşe Berna Uçarol

OpenEdition suggests that you cite this post as follows:
Ayşe Berna Uçarol (November 28, 2025). Crafting Technotopias: Insights from the STS Türkiye 2025 Conference. Manufacturing Practices of Medical Instruments (MediCluster). Retrieved November 11, 2026 from https://doi.org/10.58079/158im


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.